Newspaper Summary - 251125

 The implementation of the four new Labour Codes, which replaces 29 central laws, is presented by the sources as a major policy and business overhaul, aiming to modernize archaic employment statutes and enhance worker protection while promoting ease of doing business. This extensive reform takes place amidst several other key business and financial updates, including significant regulatory shifts and market volatility.

I. The New Labour Codes: Scope and Policy Intent

The Central government announced the nationwide implementation of four Labour Codes on a Friday, calling it a "historic step" to ensure "dignity for every worker". These reforms consolidate India's employment statutes into four codes:

1. Code of Wages (2019).
2. Industrial Relations Code (2020).
3. Code on Social Security (2020).
4. Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code (OSHWC) (2020).

Prime Minister Narendra Modi hailed the move as one of the most comprehensive and progressive labour-oriented reforms since Independence, noting that it "greatly empowers our workers" and "significantly simplifies compliance and promotes Ease of Doing Business". For employers, better visibility of labour laws and easier compliances are expected to encourage the international business community to set up in India.

II. Key Changes and Sectoral Impact

The new framework introduces several major statutory changes affecting compliance, compensation, and worker welfare:

1. Redefinition of Wages and Impact on Benefits

A key feature across all four codes is the revised definition of ‘wages’, which now mandates that basic pay, dearness allowance (DA), and retaining allowance must constitute at least 50% of the total remuneration (Cost-to-Company or CTC).

• Gratuity and Social Security: This change ensures consistency in calculating gratuity, pension, and social security benefits. Previously, employers often minimized basic pay/DA to reduce benefit payouts. Now, setting a floor of 50% for deemed wages will result in a "huge increase" in gratuity payouts and higher contributions to Provident Fund (PF) and Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC).
• Employment Costs: While this benefits employees—particularly lower-income workers who will have greater retirement savings—it will increase costs for employers, who may pass those costs on, potentially leading to an adverse impact on employees' take-home salaries.
• Fixed-Term Employment: The codes extend gratuity eligibility to fixed-term employees after just one year of continuous service, moving away from the previous five-year norm. These workers are also entitled to the same benefits as permanent employees for the duration of their contract.

2. Protection for Gig and Platform Workers

Perhaps the most significant expansion of social protection is the formal recognition of 'gig work,' 'platform work,' and 'aggregators'.

• Mandatory Contributions: Aggregators (like e-commerce and logistics firms) must contribute 1-2% of their annual turnover, capped at 5% of the amount paid/payable to gig/platform workers, towards social security.
• Business Impact: This mandatory social security contribution is expected to increase operational costs for e-commerce players, affecting large cost centers like delivery fleets and warehouse manpower in the short term, though it brings clarity and uniformity in the long term.
• Regulatory Challenges: Experts point out that several states (including Rajasthan, Karnataka, Jharkhand, Telangana, and Bihar) have already enacted their own gig worker laws, which may create overlaps and require more clarity in coming days.

3. Worker Welfare and Inclusion

The reforms introduce widespread welfare measures:

• Universal Coverage: The new framework extends basic social security and minimum wage guarantees to over 400 million workers across formal and informal sectors. Labour Minister Mansukh Mandaviya stated that 40 crore workers would come under a strengthened social security framework.
• Safety and Health: Workers over 40 are entitled to free annual health check-ups. Full health security is guaranteed for workers in hazardous sectors.
• Equality: The codes mandate equal pay for women and permit women workers to work night shifts and in all types of work (including underground mining), subject to consent and safety measures. Textile industry leaders believe removing night shift restrictions will boost productivity and global competitiveness.

III. Implementation Challenges and Opposition

Despite the high praise from the government and industry, the rollout faces operational and political challenges:

• Concurrent List/State Rules: Since labour is part of the Concurrent List, implementation requires individual State governments to notify their specific rules. Experts note that the success of the reforms hinges on how states implement the finer rules, as actual compliance happens at the state level.
• State Resistance: Some major states have resisted the changes. West Bengal is among the major states that have not drafted rules under any of the four categories, and the State Labour Minister previously stated the state will not comply.
• Opposition from Unions: Central trade unions fiercely rejected the codes, announcing nationwide "combative resistance and defiance" on November 26. A joint statement from 10 central trade unions condemned the "blatantly unilateral implementation of anti-worker, pro-employer labour codes," warning that the new framework dilutes worker protections and weakens the trade union movement.
• MSME Burden: The consolidation of laws is likely to lead to higher costs for MSMEs and smaller companies. An executive noted that smaller firms may struggle with expanded ESIC coverage and enhanced safety norms, potentially pushing them to limit their workforce below compliance thresholds.
• Institutional Gaps: A significant challenge lies in establishing the institutional structures for effective implementation, citing the long-standing difficulty in registering construction workers for the Cess Fund or the low registration rate (about five lakh out of an estimated 1 crore) on the e-Shram portal for gig workers.

IV. Context of Key Business, Financial, and Policy Updates

The Labour Code implementation is one of several major policy shifts announced in the broader business environment:

Update Area	Key Development	Details from Sources
Monetary/Currency	Rupee Hits All-Time Low	The rupee saw its biggest single-day drop recently, closing at an all-time low of 89.48/dollar (or 89.66/dollar in another source). This was attributed to a worsening trade deficit, dollar strengthening due to expectations the US Fed may not cut interest rates in December, and uncertainty over progress in US tariffs.
Regulatory (SEBI)	SEBI Overhauls Investment Trusts and Regulations	SEBI is exploring measures to expand the investment pool for REITs and InvITs, including facilitating the inclusion of REITs in stock market indices. SEBI is also considering proposals to overhaul the Mutual Funds Regulations (1996) and Stock Broker Regulations (1992) to remove redundant rules and facilitate ease of doing business.
Trade Policy	PLI for Aerospace Components	Top global aerospace firms (including Airbus and Boeing) are urging India to introduce a Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme for aerospace components to prevent India from missing out on major manufacturing shifts, citing aggressive incentives offered by countries like Morocco and Turkey.
Digital Infrastructure	UPI-TIPS Interlinking	The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) agreed to start the "realisation phase" for interlinking India’s UPI with the Eurosystem’s TARGET Instant Payment Settlement (TIPS), aiming to facilitate cross-border remittances.
Retail Economy	GST Impact on Sales	Retailers saw an 11% festival growth, partly attributed to GST cuts and regional demand. GST rate cuts led to broad-based disinflation in consumer durables and automobiles, though transmission was uneven across FMCG goods.
Real Estate/IBC	Bankruptcy Reform Consultation	The government and IBBI are examining a framework to tailor bankruptcy resolution for real estate at the level of individual projects or towers, instead of the current corporate entity level. This approach is welcomed by industry bodies like NAREDCO for protecting homebuyers but raises policy questions about diluting deterrence against financial indiscipline.

The rollout of the Labour Codes, focused on enhancing social protection and simplifying compliance, reflects a broader policy effort—seen in SEBI’s reforms for capital markets and discussions on IBC changes for real estate—to create a more structured and predictable operating environment to support economic growth. However, similar to the mixed results of GST cuts (quick transmission in autos/durables, slow in FMCG), the success of the Labour Codes relies heavily on harmonious and effective implementation across state lines.

---

The implementation of the New Labour Codes, while celebrated as a simplification measure for ease of doing business, acts like a complex gearbox: it consolidates 29 old, fragmented parts into four powerful gears designed for modern machinery (the economy). However, since labor is controlled both centrally and locally, engaging those gears—especially the new rules regarding wages, gratuity, and gig work—requires precise coordination from every state. Without this smooth alignment, the system risks friction, leading to increased costs for smaller businesses and strong resistance from traditional unions.

The sources outline significant activity and proposed reforms by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), aimed at modernizing capital markets, ensuring investor protection, promoting digital payment linkages, and stabilizing financial instruments, all within a context of currency volatility and broader economic policy shifts.

I. Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) Reforms

SEBI’s current efforts are largely focused on enhancing market liquidity, simplifying regulations, and expanding investor access, particularly to alternative investment products.

A. Deepening Investment in REITs and InvITs

SEBI is actively pursuing measures to expand the investment pool for Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Infrastructure Investment Trusts (InvITs). The goal is to improve liquidity and attract larger institutional and retail participation.

• Equity Reclassification and Index Inclusion: SEBI is working to facilitate the inclusion of REITs in stock market indices. The regulator took a major step in September by approving the classification of REIT units as equity (while InvITs remain classified as 'hybrid'). This reclassification enables equity mutual funds (MFs) to allocate more meaningfully to REITs within their equity limits, thereby paving the way for index inclusion and passive fund flows.
• Expanding Investment Pools: SEBI is examining proposals to expand the pool of liquid MF schemes in which REITs and InvITs can invest, while safeguarding investor interests. The regulator is also exploring whether private InvITs may invest in greenfield projects, subject to adequate safeguards.
• Institutional Coordination and Retail Awareness: SEBI is engaging with institutional investors and coordinating with entities like the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI), Pension Fund Regulatory and Development Authority (PFRDA), and EPFO (Employees' Provident Fund Organisation) to facilitate their greater participation in these instruments. Despite measures like lowering entry thresholds for InvITs, retail awareness remains low, estimated at around 10%, with penetration below 1%.

B. Regulatory Overhaul for Ease of Doing Business

SEBI plans to undertake major updates to existing regulations to simplify compliance and facilitate business ease. The SEBI board is likely to consider two major overhaul proposals at its meeting on December 17:

1. Mutual Funds Regulations (1996) Overhaul: Proposals include refining the total expense ratio (TER) framework. Specifically, SEBI plans to remove the additional 5 basis points (bps) that asset management companies (AMCs) were previously allowed to levy across MF schemes.
2. Stock Broker Regulations (1992) Overhaul: The intent is to remove redundant regulations and make them more relevant.
   • Unbundling Brokerage Fees: The regulator is considering breaking down the broking fee charged to investors. The current embedded fee of 12 paise per transaction might be reduced to about 2 paise, requiring investors to pay separately for research provided by brokers. This aims to provide investors clarity on what they are paying for, although the industry has pushed back, arguing that unbundling could sharply reduce research budgets.
   • Algorithmic Trading: SEBI proposed introducing a definition of ‘algorithmic trading’ to streamline compliance, noting that the original regulations were framed 30 years ago.
3. Internal Conflict of Interest: The December 17 meeting will also consider a report proposing wide-ranging reforms, including enhanced disclosures and a "zero-tolerance" approach to conflicts of interest among senior officials within the regulator.

C. Investor Protection and Digital Gold

In response to the growing popularity of digital gold, SEBI issued a circular earlier this month cautioning investors.

• Lack of Regulation: SEBI clarified that digital gold is neither categorized as a security nor a commodity derivative and operates entirely outside its purview.
• Risk Warning: The regulator emphasized that digital gold products may entail significant risks for investors, including counterparty and operational risks.
• Market Opportunity: Mutual fund houses are capitalizing on this regulatory clarity by launching prominent campaigns positioning Gold ETFs as the safer, regulated, and transparent alternative for gold exposure via the stock market.

II. Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and Monetary Context

The RBI is focused on integrating India's digital payments globally, managing currency stability, and steering the bond market amidst fiscal pressure.

A. Global Digital Payment Integration (UPI-TIPS)

The RBI has agreed to start the "realisation phase" for interlinking India’s Unified Payments Interface (UPI) with the Eurosystem’s TARGET Instant Payment Settlement (TIPS), following constructive engagement with the European Central Bank. This UPI–TIPS link aims to facilitate cross-border remittances between India and the eurozone, benefiting users on both sides by slashing transfer costs and settlement friction.

B. Currency Volatility and Market Stress

The Indian currency faced significant downward pressure, reflecting global and domestic economic uncertainties:

• Rupee at All-Time Low: The rupee saw its biggest single-day drop in recent times, breaching the 89-to-the-dollar mark and closing at an all-time low of 89.48/dollar (or 89.66/dollar).
• Driving Factors: This decline was attributed to a worsening trade deficit ($41.68 billion in October), aggressive short-covering triggered when the rupee breached the 88.80 level, and the dollar gaining strength due to expectations that the US Fed may not cut interest rates in December.
• RBI Intervention: The slide also coincided with the withdrawal of RBI intervention (sell USD support) and the breaching of the 88.80 psychological defense level, suggesting the RBI wanted to keep reserves dry for intervention at higher levels.

C. Banking and G-Sec Market Challenges

RBI policies and overall market dynamics have impacted bank balance sheets:

• G-Sec Aversion: Banks’ treasuries have adopted a cautious stance on buying Government Securities (G-Secs). This reluctance is driven by concerns over the fiscal impact of measures like the 8th Pay Commission and, crucially, tighter investment guidelines issued by the RBI.
• Regulatory Constraint: The revision in investment guidelines limits the flexibility of banks in managing their Held-to-Maturity (HTM) portfolios, with sales from this book capped sharply at 5%, constraining portfolio rebalancing.
• Credit-Deposit Ratio: The overall credit-deposit (CD) ratio for banks eased slightly to 80.2% but remained above the 80% mark, signaling a challenge in mobilizing deposits as customers shift to higher-yielding alternative investment products.

III. Financial Reforms in the Larger Policy Context

The simultaneous financial and economic updates underscore a policy drive towards formalization, global integration, and regulatory efficiency:

1. Regulatory Efficiency and Easing Business: SEBI's mandate to simplify MF and broker rules aligns directly with the government's push for Ease of Doing Business—a parallel objective noted in the nationwide implementation of the New Labour Codes, which aims to replace 29 fragmented laws with four simplified codes.
2. Infrastructure Funding and Policy Innovation: SEBI's efforts to deepen REITs/InvITs complements the broader effort to attract investment into infrastructure. This is also mirrored by the government and IBBI (Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India) examining a framework to tailor bankruptcy resolution specifically for the real estate sector at the level of individual projects or towers, shifting away from the corporate entity level to protect homebuyers.
3. Market Performance and Investor Behavior: The strong financial performance of India Inc in Q2 FY26 was marked by outperformance from mid- and small-cap companies and significant non-core income. SEBI's push for REIT inclusion and the caution against digital gold indicate regulatory efforts to direct this rising domestic capital (often fueled by retail/HNI growth, as noted in the PMS/AIF boom in previous conversations) toward regulated, transparent instruments.

These coordinated efforts across SEBI and RBI illustrate a dual focus: creating streamlined, transparent regulatory systems for market participants (SEBI's ease of doing business) while simultaneously developing the digital infrastructure for global transactions (RBI’s UPI-TIPS), thereby laying the groundwork for India's growing role in global finance.

---

The current regulatory landscape resembles a financial mechanic overhauling a car for a global rally. SEBI is refining the internal engine parts—tuning up REITs for better performance (reclassifying them as equity for indexing) and modernizing outdated rules (overhauling broker regulations)—to make the machine run smoother and more transparently for investors. Meanwhile, the RBI is installing global communication systems (linking UPI to TIPS) for international interaction, even as the currency gauge (the Rupee) is flashing red due to external pressure and trade imbalance. The overall goal is speed and efficiency, but the journey involves careful internal checks and managing external volatility.

The sources detail robust, yet selective, corporate and sectoral growth across India, heavily influenced by government policy initiatives like GST cuts, major labour law reforms, and targeted infrastructure/defense spending.

I. Sectoral Growth Drivers and Consumption Trends

A. Retail and Consumption Boom (Driven by Policy)

The retail sector experienced significant momentum, partially fueled by regulatory changes:

• Retailers recorded 11% festival growth over the 87-day festival period (August 1 to October 26, 2025). This uplift was attributed partly to festival buying and GST rate cuts (the "GST Bachat Mahotsav").
• The highest performing category was the quick service restaurants segment, which grew by 15%. Other strong performers included Furniture and Furnishing (13% growth) and Food & Grocery, Jewellery, and Footwear (12% growth each).
• Consumer spending was selective, showing a preference for value-driven categories. Apparel and footwear priced below ₹2,500 saw stronger traction than premium products.

B. Impact of GST Cuts on Specific Sectors

The sources provide direct evidence of how policy rates impact consumer prices:

• The GST rate reductions, effective from September 22, led to broad-based disinflation in consumer durables and automobiles.
• Automobiles witnessed the highest disinflationary trends, with four-wheeler inflation declining 7 percentage points in October. This corresponds to the GST on automobiles moving from 28% to 18%.
• Consumer electronics saw quick pass-throughs, with average deflation of 2.5% in October. For instance, television prices recorded inflation of -4.3%.
• However, the response was uneven across FMCG goods, with sectors like non-alcoholic beverages, personal care, and packaged foods showing sticky pricing or delayed pass-throughs.

C. Automotive Sector Developments

The automotive sector saw multiple updates regarding products and strategic investment:

• Hyundai is actively targeting the compact SUV segment lead with the all-new Venue model.
• Hero MotoCorp launched the Glamour X 125cc commuter bike, equipped with advanced electronics unusual for its segment, such as ride-by-wire throttle, multiple ride modes, and cruise control.
• Ather Energy, an electric two-wheeler maker, expanded its international market presence by launching its Rizta family scooter in Sri Lanka.
• In terms of safety and corporate caution, Toyota Kirloskar Motor recalled 11,529 units of its Urban Cruiser Hyryder SUV to inspect and replace a dashboard component.

II. Corporate Strategy, Investment, and Structural Shifts

A. Capital Expenditure and Manufacturing

Several companies announced significant capital commitments, signaling expansion plans:

• Greenply Industries lined up ₹800 crore in capital expenditure over the next two to three years to establish a greenfield plywood plant and a new MDF facility, intending to regain its top position in the plywood industry.
• Tata Chemicals approved a ₹910 crore expansion plan for its manufacturing capacities of dense soda ash (in Mithapur) and precipitated silica (in Cuddalore).
• Companies like Welspun Corp Ltd (pipes) and Waaree Energies Ltd (solar modules/cells) are preparing to capitalize on the massive wave of data-center construction in the US, driven by Artificial Intelligence (AI) and cloud computing, recognizing the resultant demand for dedicated power supplies and related infrastructure.

B. Technology, Fintech, and Digital Economy

The digital and tech sectors continue to show high growth and expansion, often focused on customer acquisition and market dominance:

• Maruti Suzuki India (MSIL) invested nearly ₹2 crore for a 7.84% equity stake in the tech start-up Ravity Software Solutions through its Innovation Fund, marking its third such strategic investment.
• Fintech platform Groww (parent Billionbrains Garage Ventures) reported a strong Q2 FY26 net profit increase of 12% y-o-y to ₹471.3 crore. The company emphasized a focus on customer-first philosophy and building long-term value, with monetization following naturally.
• E-commerce and fashion platforms like Myntra and Nykaa are seeing growth driven by the strong traction for their quick delivery services in top cities. D2C beauty brand Plum is expanding into tier-2 and tier-3 markets, experiencing mid-teens revenue growth from quick commerce.
• Aerospace startup Agnikul raised ₹150 crore in a Series C round.

C. Pharma and Diagnostics (GLP-1 Wave)

The global rise of new anti-obesity drugs is creating a specialized growth sector domestically:

• Global pharmaceutical company Eli Lilly hit a $1 trillion market value, becoming the first drug-maker to reach this milestone, largely driven by the explosive success of its weight-loss drugs (Mounjaro and Zepbound).
• In India, Eli Lilly’s Mounjaro quickly rose to be the top-selling brand in October, with monthly sales of ₹100 crore.
• This anti-obesity wave is fostering a new growth engine for diagnostics chains, including Tata 1mg, Thyrocare Technologies, and Metropolis Healthcare. These labs are developing and curating specialized testing packages to monitor cardiac, liver, pancreatic, and metabolic markers for patients on GLP-1 therapies.

III. Financial Performance and Policy Context

A. Overall India Inc Performance (Q2 FY26)

India Inc delivered strong overall figures, though the recovery was selective:

• Aggregate net profit jumped 34% y-o-y, the highest since Q2 FY24, while total income rose 7.5% y-o-y.
• Operational revenue grew 6.5% y-o-y, and sales volumes (excluding OMCs and BFSI) climbed 8% y-o-y.
• The strong profit growth was heavily supported by non-core income, which surged almost 50% y-o-y.
• However, analysis indicated a shallow recovery, largely driven by small and mid-cap outperformance and inflated by oil marketing companies (OMCs) rebounding from a low base. The share of fast-growing companies has been shrinking, with many firms seeing very weak (0-10%) or negative growth.

B. Regulatory and Structural Developments

Corporate activities are constantly adapting to policy shifts and market volatility:

• Corporate Restructuring: Vedanta’s proposed demerger into five listed entities is expected to unlock about ₹84 per share in additional value in each vertical. Kotak Mahindra Bank announced a 1:5 stock split to make its shares more affordable and enhance liquidity, pending regulatory approval.
• Real Estate Regulation: The government and IBBI are considering tailoring bankruptcy resolution for the real estate sector down to the level of individual projects or towers, shifting away from the corporate entity level. This aims to protect homebuyers but raises policy questions about diluting deterrence against financial indiscipline.
• Aerospace PLI Demand: The push by major global aerospace OEMs (Airbus, Boeing) for a PLI scheme for components highlights the need for targeted industrial policy to maintain global competitiveness against countries offering aggressive incentives.
• Labour Code Impact: The implementation of the new Labour Codes is a fundamental structural change for all companies, affecting employment costs and operational compliance, particularly through the redefinition of 'wages' for calculating gratuity and social security, and the formal inclusion of gig workers. Conversely, the IT industry anticipates greater clarity and predictability, and the textile sector expects a boost to productivity through the removal of night shift restrictions for women.
• Supply Chain Strain: The global chip scarcity is negatively impacting the costs of laptops and budget smartphones, with industry executives anticipating broader price revisions in 2026 due to input cost pressures like the surge in memory chip costs.

---

Corporate India is operating amidst a turbulent backdrop where global inflation (leading to rising memory chip costs) and currency volatility (Rupee hitting all-time lows) clash with domestic consumption stimulus (GST cuts driving retail sales) and massive regulatory overhaul (Labour Codes and SEBI reforms). The prevailing dynamic is one of selective outperformance: while the overall net profit figures look strong, driven by large, defensive players and buoyant non-core income, underlying sales volume growth and broad-based recovery are still described as shallow. Companies are responding by making strategic shifts, such as focusing on asset monetization (REITs/InvITs), committing large capex to manufacturing (Greenply, Tata Chemicals), and positioning for new growth avenues like AI-driven infrastructure (Welspun) and specialized healthcare diagnostics.

The sources highlight that India’s engagement in the international sphere currently centers on major diplomatic summits, critical trade revival efforts (particularly in geopolitically sensitive regions), and proactive policy integration through financial and industrial initiatives. These international relations and policies are intrinsically linked to the government’s concurrent domestic agenda focused on modernization and ease of doing business.

I. Diplomatic and Multilateral Policy Engagement

The government is actively participating in high-level multilateral forums, setting the stage for global cooperation on critical issues.

1. G20 Summit Focus

Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrived in Johannesburg to attend the G20 Leaders’ Summit hosted by South Africa. His stated goal was to have "productive discussions" on key global issues, focusing on strengthening cooperation, advancing development priorities, and ensuring a better future for all.

The summit sessions address a wide range of policy concerns reflecting the global economic and environmental agenda:

• Inclusive and Sustainable Economic Growth: This session covers the role of trade, financing for development, and the debt burden.
• A Resilient World: Topics include Disaster Risk Reduction, Climate Change, Just Energy Transitions, and Food Systems.
• A Fair and Just Future for All: This session focuses on Critical Minerals, Decent Work, and Artificial Intelligence (AI).

2. COP30 Climate Showdown

The ongoing COP30 international climate summit in Belém, Brazil, faces significant policy contention. The ambitious agenda items include increasing climate finance to developing countries and protecting indigenous rights. However, a consensus is missing on the crucial item: a timeline to phase out fossil fuels (oil, coal, and gas). This opposition comes mainly from petro-states and is intensified by the "complete lack of financial assistance" offered by rich countries for the transition.

II. International Trade, Connectivity, and Geopolitical Relations

India is focused on integrating its financial infrastructure globally and reviving historically important trade routes amidst regional tensions.

1. Financial Integration (UPI-TIPS)

A key regulatory update demonstrating India’s push for global financial connectivity is the initiation of the implementation phase for interlinking India’s Unified Payments Interface (UPI) with the Eurosystem’s TARGET Instant Payment Settlement (TIPS). This collaboration between the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the European Central Bank is expected to facilitate cross-border remittances between India and the eurozone, benefiting users by reducing costs and friction.

2. Trade Revival with Afghanistan

India is actively working to revive economic ties with Afghanistan, following a sharp dip in bilateral trade after the 2021 regime change.

• Trade Status: Bilateral trade fell below $1 billion in FY25, down from a high of $1.5 billion before 2021. The recent reopening of New Delhi’s Kabul embassy and resumption of projects have raised expectations for businesses involved in sectors like jewellery, dry fruits, textiles, and mining.
• Chabahar Port and Sanctions: Afghanistan's Commerce and Industry Minister Alhaj Nooruddin Azizi is actively pushing for the completion of the India-developed Chabahar port (in Iran, bypassing Pakistan) and views its full operationalization as essential, especially following the recent escalation in tension with Pakistan and the blocking of transit routes by Islamabad.
• The Minister called US sanctions on Chabahar port investments, which are lifted for periods as short as six months, "very unfair". He noted that India is taking up the issue with the US, and Afghanistan also intends to negotiate with the Americans regarding the sanctions and the freezing of Afghan Central Bank assets.
• Logistics and Corridors: Afghan businessmen stressed the need for the Wagah-Attari route to reopen for swift, two-day shipments. In response, India agreed to activate air freight corridors (Kabul-New Delhi and Kabul-Amritsar) to significantly enhance connectivity and strengthen trade ties. India and Afghanistan also agreed to depute trade attachés and reactivate the Joint Working Group on trade.

3. US Trade and Currency Pressure

India's financial markets remain sensitive to US policy decisions. The rupee plunged to an all-time low of 89.48/dollar (or 89.66/dollar) partly due to the lack of visibility on progress in talks on US tariffs on Indian goods and currency strengthening based on US Fed interest rate expectations. However, broader US-China de-escalation and US Asia-focused trade deals have reportedly lifted market sentiment across the metals complex, supporting aluminium prices.

4. Resumption of China Tourist Visas

In a diplomatic move to rebuild ties following the resolution of the eastern Ladakh military stand-off, India has resumed offering tourist visas for Chinese nationals through Indian missions and consulates.

III. Policy Alignment: Domestic Reforms and Global Competitiveness

Domestic policy updates, such as comprehensive labour reform and industrial incentives, are explicitly aimed at improving India's global standing and attractiveness for investment.

1. Ease of Doing Business and Labour Codes

The implementation of the four new Labour Codes, replacing 29 central laws, is viewed as a significant step to promote "Ease of Doing Business". This simplification and enhanced compliance environment is intended to "encourage the international business community to set up in India". Furthermore, the consolidation of labour laws aims to give the domestic IT sector greater clarity and predictability.

2. Strategic Industrial Incentives (PLI)

Global aerospace firms, including Boeing, Airbus, and Pratt & Whitney, are urgently requesting India implement a Production-Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme for aerospace components. They warn that countries like Morocco, Turkey, and Japan are rolling out aggressive incentives, putting India at risk of missing out on major manufacturing shifts. This industry push is supported by the context of existing, similar programs, such as the approved ₹7,300 crore PLI scheme for rare earth magnets, which is central to New Delhi's strategy to reduce reliance on China for critical components used in energy transition technologies.

The convergence of global diplomacy (G20, COP30), strategic bilateral outreach (Afghanistan, China), and domestic policy reform (Labour Codes for global business appeal, PLIs for industrial competitiveness) demonstrates a cohesive governmental focus on securing India's economic position and integrating its financial and industrial capabilities onto the world stage. This strategy faces headwinds, however, from currency volatility linked to external monetary policy and the need to navigate complex geopolitical pressures related to infrastructure development and trade tariffs.

Newspaper Summary - 211125

 The sources detail a complex picture of Financial Markets and Investment in November 2025, characterized by robust equity performance in India tempered by high valuations and specific sectoral risks, alongside significant movement in IPOs, AI, and regulatory frameworks.

I. Indian Equity Market Performance and Outlook

Indian equity markets reached significant highs in November 2025, driven largely by bluechips and positive sentiment.

• Index Performance: Dalal Street reached a 13-month high. The Nifty 50 closed at 26,192.15, just short of its all-time record close (26,216.05 on 26 September 2024), and the Sensex closed at 85,632.68, nearing its peak of 85,836.12.
• Drivers of the Rally: The surge was led by major index heavyweights, particularly HDFC Bank and Reliance Industries. The rally was fueled by both cash buying and derivatives short-covering.
• Global Context: India is experiencing one of the broadest bull-market phases, with nearly 65% of major global indices hitting new highs in 2025. However, the Nifty’s nearly 11% climb since the beginning of the year trails major global markets such as South Korea’s Kospi (67%), Hong Kong’s Hang Seng (29%), and Japan’s Nikkei 225 (25%).
• Caution and Earnings: Despite the optimism, caution prevails over the rally's longevity. Experts are waiting for the December earnings season, viewing it as the "real moment of truth," especially since markets are betting on a return to double-digit growth after approximately ten dull quarters.

II. Investment Flows and Global Influences

The sources highlight shifting capital flows, especially concerning Foreign Portfolio Investors (FPIs), and the strong influence of the US market rally.

• FPI and DII Activity: A reason for the rekindled optimism in Indian markets is the return of FPIs, who turned net buyers in October (scooping up ₹10,167.46 crore) after selling for three consecutive months since July. FPIs net bought a provisional ₹283.65 crore on Thursday. Meanwhile, Domestic Institutional Investors (DIIs) showed strong support, lapping up ₹824.46 crore.
• Contrarian Play: FPIs have pulled out ₹69,000 crore so far in 2025 and are currently not focused on India because they are consumed by the excitement of the US tech rally ("the magnificent 7 or now the magnificent 10"). FPI flows to India are only expected to pick up if US markets fall sharply. India's equity market is held up by sentiment, scarcity of alternatives, and high valuation appeal, rather than strictly earnings strength.
• Monetary Policy and Forex: The rupee depreciated to ₹88.71 against the US dollar, driven by the broad strength of the American currency and fading odds of a rate cut by the US Federal Reserve (Fed). Minutes from the Fed's October meeting showed "strongly differing views" among officials on whether to cut rates in December, which investors had previously viewed as a near certainty. Conversely, in India, retail inflation plunging to 0.25% in October strengthens the case for the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to cut the repo rate.

III. Capital Raising, IPO Dynamics, and Alternative Investments

Fundraising activities are robust, but scrutiny is applied to market mechanics and specific asset classes.

• IPO Last-Minute Frenzy: Despite India witnessing its strongest primary market cycle, there is a dramatic shift in investor behavior where between 65% and 80% of all IPO applications now pour in on the final day of the bidding window. This preference is even more extreme among Qualified Institutional Buyers (QIBs), with 97% of their bids arriving on Day 3 in 2025, a strategy aimed at minimizing capital lock-in. This concentration strains infrastructure and distorts genuine price discovery.
• Upcoming IPOs: ICICI Prudential Asset Management Co. is close to securing Sebi approval for a potential $1.1 billion IPO (₹10,000 crore), which could help India's IPO market surpass last year's record of nearly $21 billion.
• Private Equity (PE): Global investment firm KKR has started fundraising for its fifth Asia private equity fund, aiming to raise $15 billion, potentially becoming one of the region’s largest buyout fundraisings. Private equity activity in Asia has increased as warming capital markets allow for exits via IPOs and as assets in India and Japan become more attractive.
• Mutual Funds (MFs) and Asset Management: Nippon India Mutual Fund is noted for reaching ₹7 lakh crore AUM and having 1 out of every 3 mutual fund investors in India. Mutual funds generally pay a fee to use benchmark indices, though they are substantially larger than Portfolio Management Services (PMS) firms. SEBI extended the deadline for public comments on reviewing mutual fund regulations to November 24.

IV. Corporate Financing, Lending, and Risk

The lending market, particularly non-banking financial companies (NBFCs), shows signs of stress in niche segments.

• Small Loans Against Property (LAP): Small loans against property are starting to sour for non-banks. Micro-LAP, which targets informal-sector businesses with average ticket sizes of ₹3-5 lakh, is facing difficulties, as the collateral is often difficult to enforce in tier-3 to tier-5 towns. Growth in the overall LAP segment for NBFCs is expected to slow to 27-29% in the current and next financial year, down from 32% in FY25.
• NBFC Challenges: NBFCs are facing intense competition in the prime home loan segment from state-run banks, which is expected to slow non-bank lenders' home loan growth in FY26. The sector is seeking tax relief and a dedicated refinance window similar to that provided to Housing Finance Companies.
• M&A and Investments: TPG is set to invest $1 billion in Tata Consultancy Services’ (TCS) data center business, marking TCS's first concrete step toward building this business and mitigating risk by bringing in an external investor.
• BNPL Expansion: Flipkart-backed UPI app super.money is planning a fresh push into the Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) space by partnering regulated banks and lenders to compete in the checkout-finance market.

V. Regulatory and Governance Developments

Regulators are focused on market efficiency, transparency, and consumer protection.

• FPI Regulatory Overhaul: SEBI is working towards fully digitizing the FPI registration process to reduce approval times from months to a few days. SEBI is also considering allowing FPIs to net settlements for trades executed on the same day.
• Valuation Standards (IBC): The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) has proposed a new standardized format for professionals valuing distressed assets to improve transparency, credibility, and reduce litigation risks in bankruptcy cases.
• Corporate Governance: Institutional investor opposition to shareholder resolutions eased in the first half of FY26, declining to 13% from 16% a year earlier. Key areas of continuing disagreement remain the appointment of board members (due to concerns over independence) and remuneration for directors and key executives.

VI. Thematic Investment and Risk: AI Bubble and Stablecoins

Global investment themes are dominated by the AI race, which has sparked bubble concerns, and the rising prominence of stablecoins.

• AI Investment Bubble: Investor jitters surrounding a potential AI stock-market bubble were temporarily soothed by Nvidia’s record sales and strong guidance. However, fears persist, evidenced by a Bank of America survey showing 45% of global fund managers view an AI stock-market bubble as one of the biggest risks. Bearish moves by influential investors like SoftBank and Peter Thiel, who sold their Nvidia stakes, further rattled the market.
• Stablecoin Risk: The stock of dollar-denominated stablecoins has soared from $138 billion at the start of 2024 to $308 billion in October. This growth presents a danger by potentially eroding governments’ control over money and debt, fundamentally reshaping how modern economies manage inflation, stabilize markets, and finance public spending.

---

The current financial market situation can be likened to a high-speed train carrying precious cargo: the Indian market indices are soaring like a train running on optimism and liquidity. However, the sources show the track ahead is complex: one set of engineers (the NBFCs) are flagging maintenance issues on the consumer credit routes, while the capital flow regulators (SEBI) are digitizing the engine controls to enhance speed and efficiency. Meanwhile, global markets are dominated by the spectacle of a neighboring train, the US tech rally, which threatens to pull away the necessary fuel (FPI investment), and the risk of a global AI bubble popping hangs over the entire railway network.

The corporate and sectoral landscape in November 2025 reflects a period of significant strategic investments, technological integration, and targeted regulatory adjustments, set against a backdrop of global trade challenges and domestic consumption shifts.

I. Technology, AI, and IT Sector Transformation

The sources highlight a crucial pivot in India's technology sector, characterized by massive investments in AI infrastructure and a reshaping of the employment market due to automation.

• AI Infrastructure Investment: Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) is making its first concrete step towards building a data center business by partnering with global investment firm TPG. TPG is set to invest $1 billion in this venture. TCS and TPG plan to invest up to ₹18,000 crore over the next few years. This capability is aimed at delivering complete AI solutions for customers and partners, with the long-term goal of making TCS the largest AI-led technology services company. The investment mitigates risk by involving an external investor in a capital-intensive business.
• Hiring Landscape Shift (GCCs): Automation is beginning to reshape tech hiring, causing Global Capability Centers (GCCs) to dial back on routine recruitment. This decline is concentrated in repeatable, entry-level roles. Staffing firms are impacted as IT-related hiring is a major source of revenue. However, GCCs are still hiring specialized talent in high-demand fields such as AI/ML (Artificial Intelligence/Machine Learning), cybersecurity, cloud, and data roles. Despite the slowdown in traditional roles, the CEO of WeWork projects that India’s GCC workforce could sharply rise to nearly 10–20 million over time, driven by global companies shifting from outsourcing to cost-competitive insourcing.
• SaaS Growth: Zoho One, the all-in-one business software platform, registered 39% year-on-year customer growth in India during FY25 and expects continued growth at a similar pace. Lenovo India also reported a 23% year-on-year increase in revenue for the September quarter, driven by digitization and premiumization.
• Electronics Manufacturing: The government approved ₹7,172 crore in total investment for 17 projects in the second tranche of approvals under a scheme to boost electronic goods production. Karnataka secured Letters of Intent worth ₹2,600 crore for investments, including a ₹1,500 crore HDI/Multi-layer PCB Plant by Global HDI.

II. Automotive, Defense, and Industrials

The auto sector is strategically positioning India as a global export base, while the defense and industrial sectors see capacity upgrades and technology transfers.

• Automotive Export Strategy: Global carmakers are increasingly using India as a cost-competitive manufacturing base and export hub to counter the rising dominance of Chinese car exports (which reached 5.62 million units in the first ten months of 2025).
  • Suzuki Motor Co. is tapping India as its global export hub, targeting over 100 countries.
  • Hyundai India relies on Internal Combustion Engine (ICE) models as its export backbone, focusing on emerging markets like Saudi Arabia, Mexico, and South America where EV penetration is low.
  • Mahindra Group aims for an eight-fold consolidated revenue growth in its auto sector by FY30, striving to be the world’s fastest-growing SUV brand, and targeting one million Electric Vehicles (EVs) on the road by 2031 for last-mile mobility.
  • Ashok Leyland plans to expand its diesel truck range, including launching new heavy-duty trucks with 320 and 360 horsepower ratings.
  • Tenneco Clean Air closed with 24% listing gains, benefiting from its dominant market share (57% in clean air for commercial trucks) and regulatory tailwinds like BS-VI compliance.
• Defense and Steel: The US approved the sale of Javelin anti-tank missile systems and Excalibur guided artillery projectiles to India, totaling nearly $93 million, to strengthen India’s defense capabilities. Steel Authority of India Ltd (SAIL)'s Bokaro plant signed an agreement with DRDO for the transfer of technology to manufacture DMR 249A special steel sheets for naval applications. SAIL also announced a 9.8 million tonne capacity expansion plan for its Rourkela Steel Plant.

III. Financial, Lending, and Regulatory Challenges

Corporate health in the non-banking financial sector shows localized stress, while banks and major financial companies exhibit strength.

• NBFC Asset Quality Concerns: Small Loans Against Property (LAP), especially micro-LAP (₹3–5 lakh ticket sizes) targeted at the informal sector, are starting to sour for non-banks. This deterioration is manageable but suggests strain on low-income borrowers, partly due to the difficulty in enforcing collateral in tier-3 to tier-5 towns. NBFC LAP growth is expected to slow to 27–29% in the current and next fiscal year.
• Competition and Advocacy: Non-bank lenders' home loan growth is projected to slow in FY26 due to intense competition from state-run banks aggressively targeting the prime home loan segment. NBFCs met with the Finance Minister to seek tax relief and a dedicated refinance window, similar to that provided to Housing Finance Companies.
• Brand Valuation and Stability: HDFC Bank was ranked the most-valuable Indian brand, valued at nearly $45 billion, according to the Kantar BrandZ rankings.
• Legal Overhang: The Supreme Court ordered an inquiry into allegations of "dubious transactions" against NBFC Sammaan Capital, creating a significant regulatory overhang that could temporarily depress its valuation and slow business expansion.

IV. Retail, Consumption, and Food & Beverage

Consumer behavior is marked by a flight to smaller pack sizes and a distinct trend toward premiumization in specific segments.

• Consumption Patterns: Rural sales volumes for packaged consumer goods increased by 7.7% in the September quarter, continuing to outpace urban growth (3.7%). The market is seeing a stronger consumer preference for smaller packs (unit growth outpacing volume growth).
• Grocery Leadership: Reliance Retail hired Guillaume de Colonges, former Carrefour executive, to oversee its grocery business, suggesting a strategic move and potentially laying the groundwork for succession planning ahead of a potential IPO in 2027–28.
• Beauty Premiumization: The beauty and personal care market is rapidly shifting toward prestige and specialized products, driven by consumers trading up and seeking specific, effective ingredients. Honasa Consumer launched a prestige nighttime skincare brand, Lumineve, and Nykaa added international luxury brands like La Prairie and Prada Beauty.
• Experiential Commerce: Food delivery platforms Eternal and Swiggy are aggressively moving into the dining-out and live events market to capture discretionary spending. Eternal’s "going-out" business grew 32% year-on-year in Q2 FY26, and Swiggy’s corresponding segment grew 52% year-on-year.
• Corporate Restructuring (B9 Beverages): Japan's Kirin Holdings, a large shareholder in B9 Beverages (Bira), is in discussions with stakeholders and creditors to restructure the business, management, and strategy following a funding crunch and internal unrest. Kirin clarified it has no intention to sell its stake.

V. Healthcare and Infrastructure

Sectoral developments include major healthcare expansion and critical shifts in telecom and green energy.

• Healthcare Expansion: Narayana Hrudayalaya successfully completed the acquisition of Practice Plus Group Hospitals in the UK for GBP 183 million. However, the complex structure of its integrated care model in the Cayman Islands faces challenges, currently struggling to achieve positive Ebitda due to losses in the health insurance business, leading to investor caution. Healthium Medtech announced a ₹150 crore investment for a second manufacturing unit in Sri City, expanding its operations.
• Telecom Survival (Vodafone Idea): The government, now the single largest shareholder (49%), has averted a potential telecom duopoly by supporting Vodafone Idea (Vi)'s survival. The government's decision not to take a board seat maintained Vi's status as a private sector company. However, Vi requires large amounts of capital (₹50,000–55,000 crore) for capex, contingent on clarity regarding Adjusted Gross Revenue (AGR) dues and bank funding.
• Green Energy/Battery Tech: TCG Group is considering the commercial production of indigenous sodium-ion batteries, which would eliminate India's reliance on global supply chains for materials like cobalt, nickel, copper, and lithium, often imported from China. Furthermore, India’s solar module manufacturing industry is headed toward consolidation over the next 3–5 years due to overcapacity and the requirement for technology- and capital-intensive scale. Oil India Ltd. partnered with TotalEnergies for technical assistance in deep and ultra-deepwater exploration.

The sources reflect that in November 2025, the global and domestic environment is defined by increasing trade protectionism, high-stakes geopolitical maneuvers primarily involving the US and China, and critical domestic legal and fiscal challenges in India. These factors significantly shape market sentiment and business certainty.

I. Global Geopolitics, Trade, and Sovereignty

The overarching geopolitical theme is characterized by protectionist reflexes globally, impacting trade dynamics and emphasizing national self-reliance.

• Rise of Protectionism and Fractured World: Globally, the belief in universal collaboration is being replaced by an instinct for self-preservation. This shift is fueled by sentiments of nationalism and populism. In the last two years, G20 economies have implemented over a thousand new trade barriers, including tariffs and digital service taxes, marking the return of trade protectionism.
• India's Sovereign Response: The sources argue that India’s most reliable defense in a volatile geopolitical world is the strength of its homegrown institutions. The ultimate litmus test of sovereignty in the 21st century is whether India can remain functional if the world decides to "unplug us" digitally, economically, or institutionally. This philosophy drives the need for domestic ownership of foundational infrastructure.
• US-China Rivalry: The US-China rivalry has intensified beyond economic competition to a "contest of control," involving export bans on semiconductors, restrictions on joint research, and oversight on foreign listings.
  • Cyber/Disinformation Warfare: China employed an online disinformation campaign after the India-Pakistan border stand-off (May 2025) to undermine the sale of French Rafale fighter jets to India and promote its own J-35 fighters. This was characterized as expanding use of generative AI and other digital tools to advance strategic interests without direct military confrontation.
• US Trade Relations and Market Impact: Markets experienced rekindled optimism partly because a US-India trade deal appeared closer than ever before. However, the background context is challenging:
  • India's goods trade deficit widened to a record high of $41.7 billion in October, primarily due to surging gold imports and the impact of US tariffs on Indian exports. US tariffs (doubled to 50% in August) have hit MSME-heavy export sectors.
  • The US administration reversed course on high tariffs targeting everyday goods like coffee and running shoes, an action interpreted as a response to political trends and an admission that the broad-based tariff policy was "misguided".

II. Regional Conflicts and International Cooperation

Several developments underscore attempts to strengthen economic alliances despite ongoing conflicts and instability.

• Defense Procurement: The US approved the sale of Javelin anti-tank missile systems and Excalibur guided artillery projectiles to India, valued at nearly $93 million, aimed at strengthening India's defense capabilities.
• UK-India FTA Momentum: The UK's Minister for the Indo-Pacific visited India to build momentum around the comprehensive India-UK Free Trade Agreement (FTA) signed in July. The purpose is to strengthen business links, boost investment flows, and expand technology and skills collaboration.
• Middle East and Trade: India’s Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal is visiting Israel to review the proposed India-Israel Free Trade Agreement (FTA) and enhance cooperation in fintech, defense, AI, and manufacturing. Furthermore, Amul is planning to expand dairy exports to Israel.
• Pakistan Instability: Pakistan’s military chief, Field Marshal Asim Munir, is consolidating power, including granting himself lifetime immunity and effectively undermining the constitutional framework by creating a Federal Constitutional Court. This domestic power play occurs even as the country's battered economy remains under IMF life support, and its colossal military expenditure is deemed unaffordable.

III. Domestic Socio-Political and Institutional Stability

Domestic stability is marked by political welfare spending, legal scrutiny of government actions, and institutional policy delays.

• Judicial Intervention in Governance: The Supreme Court (SC) made crucial rulings related to the legislative process:
  • The SC ruled that courts cannot impose timelines on the President or state governors to approve bills passed by state legislatures. However, the court did clarify that governors cannot indefinitely keep bills pending. Delayed assent to laws has stalled policies impacting industries like online gaming, industrial land rules, and power tariffs, thereby creating uncertainty for industries and investors.
  • The SC also struck down key provisions of the Tribunal Reforms Act of 2021, asserting that Parliament cannot undermine the independence and impartiality of tribunals through executive control over appointments.
  • The SC ordered an inquiry into alleged "dubious transactions" by NBFC Sammaan Capital, creating a "significant regulatory overhang" that could temporarily depress its valuation and slow business expansion.
• Political Fiscal Strategy: Bihar’s government, following Nitish Kumar taking oath for a 10th time, has an aggressive pre-election welfare push, budgeting ₹41,200 crore (3.8% of GDP) for subsidies and grants in FY26. This amount exceeds the state’s capital expenditure outlay, sharply weakening its fiscal position.
• Social and Environmental Issues:
  • Air Quality Crisis: The National Capital Region (NCR) continues to suffer from "very poor-severe" air quality driven by stubble burning, firecrackers, and vehicle emissions, leading to a reported 10–15% increase in respiratory cases in hospitals since Diwali.
  • Elderly Care Funding: India’s public expenditure on the long-term care of its elderly is among the lowest in the world, at 0.1% of GDP.
  • Child Poverty: Although child poverty globally has declined by one-third since 2000, two in five children worldwide still face severe deprivation.

IV. US Domestic Political Dynamics

US domestic politics influence investment and policy direction abroad.

• Trump's Policy Shifts: President Trump received criticism from some Republicans for focusing heavily on foreign policy—such as feting the Saudi Crown Prince, who promised nearly $1 trillion in US investment—while his base worried about high domestic living costs.
• Immigration: Trump indicated a shift in rhetoric, saying he would "welcome" skilled immigrants capable of developing complex products like chips and missiles, potentially causing "a little heat" from his supporters who favor immigration restrictions.

---

This period is marked by a global turn inward, where geopolitical friction (US-China rivalry, US tariffs) necessitates India to focus on building internal resilience and technological sovereignty. Meanwhile, domestic politics face stress from institutional delays in legislative assent, costly welfare spending in states like Bihar, and critical social and environmental crises like the severe air pollution in the NCR. These socio-political factors act as both drivers (geopolitical conflict pushing defense deals) and constraints (fiscal strains from welfare, legal uncertainty stalling policy) on the broader market environment.

Labor supply response on windfall gains

 The sources detail a robust survey experiment methodology designed to study the causal impact of windfall gains on labor supply, addressing major empirical challenges in labor economics.

Study Overview and Context

The study focuses on the labor supply response to wealth or unearned income shocks, recognizing this as a central question in labor economics that helps distinguish between uncompensated and compensated labor supply responses to wage changes.

Policy Relevance: Understanding the magnitude of this income effect is crucial for evaluating policies. Specifically, the research aims to inform the discussion surrounding:

• The criticism that transfer programs (like Universal Basic Income, UBI) may discourage work or job search.
• The evaluation of recent fiscal interventions, such as one-time bonuses and transfers introduced during the COVID-19 pandemic and the energy crisis.
• The design of policies that directly affect wealth, such as the taxation of inheritances or the implementation of wealth taxes.

Scope of Shocks: The methodology is explicitly designed to study labor supply responses to both more common, smaller wealth or unearned income shocks (like transfer programs) and less frequent and larger shocks (such as inheritances).

Methodology and Experimental Design

To overcome the challenge of isolating truly exogenous changes in wealth—a difficulty faced by traditional studies using non-experimental data—the authors designed a large-scale survey experiment.

Data Source and Sample:

• The experiment was conducted using the ECB’s Consumer Expectations Survey (CES), a high-frequency online panel survey capturing euro area consumer expectations and behaviors.
• The data was drawn from a special-purpose survey administered in June 2022.
• The sample is large (about 10,000 consumers total) and population-representative across the six largest euro area economies: Belgium, Germany, Italy, France, Spain, and the Netherlands.

Randomized Treatment (Windfall Gains):

• Respondents were randomly assigned to one of five hypothetical lottery winnings (windfall gains) ranging from €5,000 to €100,000.
• The randomization ensures that the resulting windfall gains are exogenous and orthogonal to respondents’ observed and unobserved characteristics, allowing the researchers to estimate the causal impact of wealth shocks on labor supply and explore heterogeneity across demographic groups.
• The range of prizes allows testing the hypothesis that responses are heterogeneous with respect to the size of the shock—a key distinction, as standard theory suggests responses should be independent of shock size unless frictions or adjustment costs are present.
• The smallest prize, €5,000, serves as the baseline or reference group for estimating the effects of larger gains.

Measured Outcomes (Three Dimensions of Labor Supply): The experiment elicited self-reported adjustments in three key dimensions of labor supply decisions over the next 12 months:

1. Extensive Margin (Employed): Employed respondents were asked about their plans for working, including the option to stop working entirely (by resigning or taking unpaid leave).
2. Intensive Margin (Employed): Employed respondents (excluding those who would stop working) were asked to indicate how many more or fewer hours they would work per week (ranging from 0 to ±11 hours or more). This focus on hours worked, rather than earnings, is an innovation that helps abstract from potential non-linearities in the wage schedule.
3. Job Search Effort (Non-Employed): Individuals not currently working (including those out of the labor force) were asked how actively they would look for a job over the next 12 months (e.g., search more, search less, stop looking, or start looking).

Empirical Framework: The study utilizes the randomization to estimate a first-difference specification of the standard labor supply equation (Equation 1). Since the windfall gain ($\beta_{i,t}$) is randomly assigned, it is independent of any unobserved variables that might affect the labor supply decision. The study uses logit regressions to estimate the probability of continuing to work (extensive margin) and OLS regressions for changes in weekly hours (intensive margin). For the non-employed, logit regressions estimate the effect on search intensity.

Methodological Advantages and Limitations

Advantages over Prior Literature: The survey experiment approach addresses several major challenges encountered by previous studies using natural or quasi-experiments (like lottery winnings or inheritances):

• Causal Identification: Random assignment ensures a clean identification of the causal effect of exogenous wealth shocks.
• Representativeness: Unlike studies relying on specific sub-groups like lottery winners or inheritance recipients, this approach uses a representative sample of the population.
• Non-linear Effects: The random variation in shock size allows the researchers to explicitly test for and identify the non-linear response of labor supply, consistent with labor market frictions or adjustment costs.
• Comprehensive Outcomes: The design captures both the extensive and intensive margins of labor supply using weekly hours worked and explicitly includes the often-overlooked dimension of search effort among the non-employed.

Acknowledged Limitations: The authors acknowledge several limitations inherent in a survey-based approach:

• Intention vs. Behavior: The responses capture intentions rather than actual realized choices, which may diverge from real-world behavior.
• Framing and Wording: Responses may be affected by differences in question wording or framing effects.
• Transitory Nature of Shock: The hypothetical windfall is a one-time shock. A rational consumer would smooth the consumption of leisure over their remaining working life, implying that the immediate labor supply response might be relatively modest.
• Tax Interpretation: The analysis assumes that individuals interpret the hypothetical windfall gain as an after-tax change in wealth.
• General Equilibrium Effects: The study analyzes only individual-level responses (partial equilibrium) and does not capture aggregate demand effects or potential intra-household spillovers (e.g., a spouse adjusting their labor supply). Thus, the estimated reduction in labor supply is likely an upper bound of the true effects.

---

Analogy to solidify understanding: The methodology employed here is like a carefully designed wind tunnel test for labor decisions. Instead of observing how actual planes (individuals) react to unpredictable, real-world gusts (actual wealth shocks, which are often correlated with unknown factors), the researchers put a representative model of a plane into a chamber and precisely control the intensity and size of the gust (the randomized hypothetical windfall). This allows them to cleanly isolate the causal impact of the "wind" (the unearned wealth) on its flight path (labor supply) without interference from other variables, even though the reaction observed is the plane's intended response in the model, not necessarily its final real-world movement.

The sources present clear key findings regarding the labor supply response to windfall gains, emphasizing a **non clear key findings regarding the labor supply response to windfall gains, emphasizing a non-linear effect where only substantial amounts lead to statistically significant reductions in work effort, which is consistent with the presence of labor market frictions.

These findings are central to the study's overall context: understanding the impact of wealth shocks on labor supply, which is critical for evaluating policy interventions such as Universal Basic Income (UBI) and fiscal stimulus transfers. The experimental design, which randomly assigns windfall gains ranging from €5,000 to €100,000, allows for the causal identification of these effects across three margins of labor supply.

Key Findings: Non-linear Labor Supply Reduction

The most important finding across all labor supply dimensions is that the negative income effect is concentrated among the largest hypothetical gains:

1. Extensive Margin (Probability of Working)

The extensive margin refers to whether employed individuals choose to exit the labor force entirely (e.g., by resigning or taking unpaid leave).

• Small Shocks (≤ €25,000): Windfall gains of €25,000 or less have no statistically significant effects on the probability of continuing to work.
• Large Shocks (€50,000 to €100,000): Gains in this substantial range reduce the probability of working by 1.5 to 3.5 percentage points. Relative to an 84% baseline employment rate, the effect is statistically significant.
• Marginal Effects: The largest prize (€100,000) reduces the likelihood of working by approximately 4 percentage points in linear regression models. Allowing for non-linear effects, the €50,000 prize reduces employment rates by 1.5 percentage points, and the €100,000 prize reduces them by 3.5 percentage points (based on logit marginal effects).

2. Intensive Margin (Hours Worked)

The intensive margin measures changes in the number of hours worked per week by those who remain employed.

• Small Shocks (≤ €25,000): Small gains produce no impact on hours worked; the effects are flat for shocks up to €25,000.
• Large Shocks (€50,000 to €100,000): Gains above €50,000 lead to a reduction of approximately one hour of work per week. Specifically, the reduction is $-0.49$ hours for a €50,000 prize and $-0.72$ hours for a €100,000 prize. This reduction is modest, corresponding to about 1.4% and 2.1% of the average 35-hour workweek, respectively.

3. Job Search Effort (Non-Employed)

The methodology also examined the impact of windfalls on job search intensity among non-employed individuals.

• Effect of Size: Search intensity, defined as the intention to search more actively or start looking for work, declines as the prize size increases.
• Linear Estimate: Search intensity declines by roughly 1 percentage point for each €10,000 gain.
• Non-linear Estimate: The disincentive effect is statistically significant for the two largest prizes (€50,000 and €100,000), reducing search intensity by 8.6 and 10 percentage points, respectively. The reduction in search intensity is also seen in descriptive statistics, which show a 10 percentage point decline across the prize distribution (from 88% to 78%).

Heterogeneity in Labor Supply Reduction

The sources highlight significant differences in response magnitude across demographic and labor market groups.

• Gender: Women respond more strongly to windfall gains than men. At the extensive margin, for the €25,000 prize, female employment rates were 2.5 percentage points lower than men, and the effect of the €50,000 prize was significant at the 10% level. At the intensive margin, women show a larger reduction in hours worked compared to men.
• Age/Proximity to Retirement: Individuals nearing retirement (older workers) exhibit a stronger reduction in labor supply. For the largest shock, the decline in the employment rate was 4 percentage points higher for older workers than younger ones, though the difference was not statistically significant at the 5% level. Older individuals also showed a more pronounced response at the intensive margin. The strongest effects on job search intensity were observed among older individuals receiving €100,000.
• Employment Status: Part-time workers respond much more to the largest wealth shock than full-time workers, showing a differential reduction in the probability of exiting the labor force of 10 percentage points (significant at the 5% level). The self-employed, who typically have greater schedule flexibility, also show a more pronounced negative effect on hours worked for large prizes.
• Country Flexibility: In countries with more flexible labor markets (proxied by the prevalence of part-time employment, such as the Netherlands), the reduction in hours worked in response to windfalls is greater than in countries with more rigid labor markets (like Italy).

Contextualizing the Findings: Policy Implications

The finding that labor supply responses are negligible for smaller shocks, but economically meaningful for large ones, has crucial policy implications.

• Transfers and UBI: The results suggest that only relatively large wealth shocks generate economically sizable labor supply responses, while smaller transfers or bonuses, typically observed in policy settings, have minimal to no disincentive effects. This implies that UBI-style programs, given their typical scale, would have quite limited labor supply disincentives.
• Fiscal Stimulus: The sources suggest that the idea that stimulus packages are ineffective because they mainly finance leisure rather than spending can be dismissed, based on the limited labor supply response to smaller shocks.
• Inheritance/Wealth Taxes: Since the largest prizes (like €100,000) are intended to model events like unanticipated inheritances, the finding of a negative, but modest, labor supply reduction suggests that eliminating inheritance or wealth taxes would likely have only small effects on employment rates and hours worked for the typical employee.

Underlying Mechanism

The observed non-linear response (effects only kick in above €25,000) is consistent with economic theories involving labor market frictions and adjustment costs. These frictions inhibit behavioral changes unless the shock is large enough to overcome the cost of adjusting work schedules or job status. Alternatively, the non-linearity could reflect behavioral biases, such as bounded rationality or mental accounting.

---

The overall key finding is that the labor supply response is not a simple, constant reaction to wealth; rather, it acts like a door that only opens when the unearned income shock is large enough to overcome the "frictional threshold" of making a life-changing decision about work. Below this threshold (around €25,000), most workers simply absorb the shock without changing their labor status or hours, suggesting that smaller, frequent transfers have little negative effect on work effort.

The sources dedicate substantial attention to exploring the heterogeneity in labor supply responses to hypothetical windfall gains, leveraging substantial attention to exploring the heterogeneity in labor supply responses to hypothetical windfall gains, leveraging the large, representative sample and the randomized experimental design. The study's design allows researchers to explore how the causal impact of wealth shocks varies across demographic and labor market groups.

The key takeaway is that certain groups exhibit a significantly stronger negative labor supply response to the substantial windfall gains (€50,000 to €100,000) than others, consistent with differences in labor market constraints, preferences, or time horizons.

Here is a detailed discussion of the heterogeneity observed across various dimensions of the labor supply response:

1. Gender

Gender emerges as a significant source of heterogeneity across both the extensive and intensive margins of labor supply.

• Extensive Margin (Probability of Working): Women show a stronger reduction in the probability of continuing to work compared to men.
  • For prizes below €25,000, the response is not statistically different between genders.
  • For the €25,000 prize, female employment rates were 2.5 percentage points lower than those of males.
  • The effect of the €50,000 prize on women's employment was significant at the 10% level.
  • These findings align with existing literature suggesting that women generally exhibit larger labor supply elasticities in response to wealth shocks.
• Intensive Margin (Hours Worked): At the intensive margin, women also exhibit a greater reduction in hours worked.
  • For the €50,000 prize level, the estimated reduction in hours worked for women was $-0.78$ hours, compared to $-0.28$ hours for men.
  • Regression results confirmed that for prizes of €50,000 and above, the estimated marginal effects on hours worked were larger (in absolute value) for women.
• Effect on Earnings: When converting the response to estimated earnings reduction for the largest shock (€100,000), the drop was larger for females (2.701%) than for males (2.264%).
• Search Intensity (Non-Employed): Although not statistically significant in the main logit regression figures, sample split results for non-employed individuals show that for prizes of €50,000 and above, the effects on search intensity are larger (in absolute value) for females than for males.

2. Age and Proximity to Retirement

The study found a pronounced negative labor supply response among older workers, which is attributed to their shorter time horizon for smoothing the income shock.

• Extensive Margin: Individuals nearing retirement (older workers) are more responsive to windfall gains.
  • For the largest wealth shock (€100,000), the decline in the employment rate was 4 percentage points higher for older workers (over 40 years old) than for younger workers (40 or younger), supporting the idea that workers closer to retirement are more responsive to economic incentives.
• Intensive Margin: Older workers also show a more pronounced response to larger prize shocks than younger workers.
  • At the €100,000 prize, older workers reduced hours by $-0.8422$ compared to $-0.5308$ hours for younger workers.
• Search Intensity: The strongest negative effects on job search intensity were observed among older individuals receiving the largest windfall (€100,000).
  • Older workers (over 40) reduced search intensity more than younger individuals in response to large prizes (€50,000 and above).
• Lifetime MPE Context: While older workers have a higher immediate earnings response, the sources note that their shorter remaining working life offsets this effect. Once differences in time horizons are accounted for, the implied lifetime MPE (Marginal Propensity to Earn) out of lifetime income is quite similar across age groups (0.137 for older versus 0.128 for young individuals for a €10,000 windfall).

3. Employment Status and Flexibility

The type of employment and the degree of labor market flexibility also influence the response magnitude.

• Part-time vs. Full-time: Part-time workers (defined as those working less than 20 hours per week) respond much more strongly to the largest wealth shock than full-time workers.
  • Part-time workers show a differential reduction in the probability of exiting the labor force of 10 percentage points compared to full-time workers (significant at the 5% level).
• Self-Employed vs. Employed: The self-employed, who typically have greater flexibility in their work schedules, show a more pronounced negative effect on hours worked for large prizes.
  • At the €100,000 prize level, the estimated reduction in hours was $-1.1$ for the self-employed, compared to $-0.6$ for employees.
• Country Flexibility: In countries characterized by more flexible labor markets (as proxied by the prevalence of part-time employment, such as the Netherlands), the reduction in hours worked in response to windfall gains is greater than in countries with more rigid labor markets (like Italy).
  • For example, the reduction in weekly hours was $-1.5$ in the Netherlands compared to $-0.5$ in Italy.

4. Financial Status and Education

Other financial and demographic characteristics showed less variation in responses:

• Indebtedness: Workers with low debt (Debt/Income ratio below one) reported a 5 percentage points higher probability of exiting the labor force in response to the largest prize compared to their highly indebted counterparts.
• Income and Education: The sources found no significant differences in the intention to continue working or the change in hours based on income level or college education.
• Financial Sophistication and Household Type: The study also found no difference in responses based on measures of financial sophistication or whether the respondent was single versus part of a different household type (e.g., single individuals without children).

In the overall context of the Labor Supply Response to Windfall Gains (Survey Experiment), the heterogeneity findings underscore the argument that labor market frictions and adjustment costs prevent small shocks from altering behavior, while large shocks trigger significant responses, particularly among groups who already possess higher labor supply elasticities (women) or face shorter time constraints (older workers/part-time workers).

The sources draw several critical policy implications and conclusions from the study's key finding: that **labor supply several critical policy implications and conclusions from the study's key finding: that labor supply responses to windfall gains are non-linear and only become economically sizable when the gains are substantial. This finding is consistent with the presence of labor market frictions or behavioral biases that inhibit changes unless the shock is large enough.

In the larger context of the Labor Supply Response to Windfall Gains (Survey Experiment), these conclusions address long-standing policy debates regarding the effectiveness of transfer programs, fiscal stimulus, and wealth taxation.

Policy Implications for Transfer Programs and Stimulus

The study’s results strongly suggest that common, smaller government transfers have minimal disincentive effects on labor supply, offering support for such interventions:

• Universal Basic Income (UBI) Programs: The results imply that only relatively large wealth shocks trigger economically meaningful labor supply responses. Since the hypothetical shocks within the range of typical transfers or bonuses result in small or negligible disincentive effects on labor supply, the sources conclude that UBI-style programs, given the scale at which they are currently discussed, would likely have quite limited labor supply disincentives effects overall. This addresses the common criticism that transfer programs may discourage work or job search.
• Fiscal Stimulus and Transfers (COVID-19/Energy Crisis): The research findings are relevant for evaluating recent fiscal interventions, such as the one-time bonuses and transfers introduced during the COVID-19 pandemic and the energy crisis. The modest labor supply response to smaller shocks suggests that the argument that stimulus packages are ineffective because they mainly finance leisure rather than consumption can be dismissed. Weakened aggregate demand effects of fiscal stimulus due to individuals consuming more leisure and earning less is a concern that the study's findings alleviate for typical transfer sizes.
• Threshold of Response: The critical finding is that gains of €25,000 or less have no statistically significant effects on the extensive margin (probability of working) or the intensive margin (hours worked). This highlights a "threshold" effect where the negative income effect only activates for large shocks (€50,000 to €100,000).

Policy Implications for Wealth and Inheritance Taxation

The study also provides empirical context for the design of policies that directly affect wealth, such as the taxation of inheritances or the implementation of wealth taxes. The largest prizes (€50,000 to €100,000) in the experiment are intended to model large, infrequent shocks like bequests or gifts.

• Modest Effects of Large Shocks: The sources find that even for the largest hypothetical shocks (unanticipated inheritances), the labor supply reduction is negative but ultimately modest.
  • For the largest gains (€50,000 to €100,000), the probability of working is reduced by 1.5 to 3.5 percentage points.
  • Hours worked reduction is about one hour per week.
• Carnegie Conjecture and Tax Elimination: The taxation of inheritances is often debated based on principles of equity and efficiency, related to the "Carnegie conjecture" that taxing inheritances reduces inequality but may increase inefficiency by reducing work effort. Since the labor supply responses to these large prizes are found to be statistically significant but modest, the sources conclude that eliminating inheritance or wealth taxes would likely have only small effects on employment rates and hours worked for the typical employee.

Conclusions and Contribution to Literature

The study concludes that its novel approach—a large-scale, population-representative survey experiment with randomized shock size—successfully estimates the causal effect of wealth shocks on three dimensions of labor supply (extensive margin, intensive margin, and job search intensity).

• Non-Linearity Mechanism: The non-linear labor supply response is the crucial finding, attributed to the presence of labor market frictions and adjustment costs (or, alternatively, behavioral biases like bounded rationality or mental accounting). This non-linearity is a key distinction from standard labor supply theory, which suggests the response should be independent of shock size.
• Heterogeneity: The findings demonstrate that responses are stronger for certain groups, particularly women and individuals nearing retirement, supporting the idea that these groups have greater labor supply elasticities or shorter horizons over which to smooth the shock.
• Comparison to Existing Literature: The study’s estimate of the implied lifetime Marginal Propensity to Earn (MPE) for a $10,000 windfall ($-0.19$) falls in the ballpark of estimates from studies using actual lottery data in Sweden and the U.S. (e.g., Cesarini et al., 2017, estimated $-0.18$). However, the study notes that its estimate for the largest shock (€100,000) yields a higher MPE ($-0.52$), which closely matches estimates from studies focused on very large lottery prizes, indicating that the non-linear response identified is consistent with real-world observed behavior.

Areas for Future Research

The sources also suggest several avenues for extending this research design:

• Asymmetric Effects: Testing for asymmetric labor supply effects by eliciting responses to hypothetical negative wealth shocks (e.g., stock market downturns, wealth taxes, housing crashes).
• Spillover Effects: Exploring the role of intra-household spillover effects (e.g., spouses adjusting labor supply) and the distinction between before- and after-tax wealth changes.
• General Equilibrium: Recognizing that the current estimates are likely an upper bound of the true effects because they do not capture positive labor demand effects that occur when windfall gains are spent (general equilibrium effects).
• 
  

Money in the modern economy (published in 2014)

 The nature of modern money, in the larger context of the modern economy, is defined by its role as a universally trusted financial claim, fundamentally operating as a special kind of IOU. Money is essential to the workings of a modern economy.

The sources emphasize three key aspects regarding the nature of modern money: its conceptual foundation as an IOU, its distinction from historical forms, and its composition based on which sector issues the debt.

I. The Conceptual Nature of Modern Money

Money in the modern economy is understood as a financial asset.

IOU and Trust: Money solves the problems inherent in complex webs of individual IOUs (promises to repay someone at a later date), which become unwieldy and rely on everyone trusting everyone else. Money is a social institution that resolves this lack of trust by being a special kind of IOU that everyone in the economy trusts. Because it is universally trusted, people are willing to accept it in exchange for goods and services.

Financial Asset vs. Liability: As a financial asset, money represents a claim on someone else in the economy. Crucially, one person's financial asset (money) is always someone else’s financial liability (debt). If all financial assets and liabilities were pooled together for the entire economy, they would cancel out, leaving only the non-financial assets (such as land or houses).

Distinction from Commodity Money: Historically, money was often commodity money—goods or assets valuable in their own right, like gold or iron, which served monetary functions. In contrast, money in the modern economy is a financial asset. Specifically, modern currency (banknotes and coin) is fiat money, meaning it is not convertible to any other asset (such as gold or other commodities).

II. Composition and Creation of Modern Money

The economy is divided into three main groups: the central bank, commercial banks, and consumers (households and companies). There are three main types of money circulating, each representing an IOU between these sectors.

Type of Money	Issuer (Debtor)	Holder (Creditor/Asset)	Proportion/Function
Bank Deposits	Commercial Banks	Consumers	Majority of money (97% of money held by the public in the UK as of December 2013). Created when banks make loans.
Currency (Fiat)	Central Bank (e.g., Bank of England)	Consumers or Commercial Banks	Small proportion of money held by the public. Primarily banknotes, which are fiat money.
Central Bank Reserves	Central Bank (e.g., Bank of England)	Commercial Banks	Used as an electronic medium of exchange for commercial banks to transact with each other.

Bank Deposits (Broad Money): Most money in the modern economy is in the form of bank deposits, which are created by commercial banks themselves. These deposits are an IOU from commercial banks to consumers. When a bank issues a loan, it simply credits the customer's account with a higher deposit balance, instantly creating new money. Bank deposits are typically held electronically and are widely used as the medium of exchange. Broad money is defined as currency held by the private sector plus bank deposits.

Currency (Fiat Money): Currency, consisting mostly of banknotes, is an IOU from the central bank. The banknotes are a "promise to pay" the holder and are shown as a liability on the central bank's balance sheet and an asset on the holder's balance sheet. Since it is fiat money, the debt can only be repaid in more fiat money. The state plays a role in underpinning the use of currency by accepting it for tax payments and deeming it "legal tender". The usefulness of currency is maintained because the central bank aims to safeguard its value through a low and stable rate of inflation.

Central Bank Reserves (Base Money): Central bank reserves are a different type of IOU from the central bank, held exclusively by commercial banks. These reserves are electronic records that allow banks to conduct large-volume transactions with each other, acting as a medium of exchange for commercial banks, similar to how current accounts work for consumers. Base money (or central bank money) comprises currency plus central bank reserves.

III. The Role of Money in the Exchange Economy

The move toward an exchange economy, away from a subsistence economy where people only consume what they produce, requires money. Money traditionally fulfills three important roles:

1. Medium of Exchange: Money is something people hold specifically to swap for something else. This has often been viewed as its most important function by economists.
2. Store of Value: Money is expected to retain its value in a reasonably predictable way over time.
3. Unit of Account: Money is the item used to price goods and services (e.g., on menus or contracts).

These functions are interconnected: an asset that is a poor store of value (like currency during hyperinflation) is less useful as a medium of exchange. Likewise, it is generally efficient for the medium of exchange to also be the unit of account.

The stability of modern money is maintained by ensuring that it retains its value. For instance, abandoning the gold standard in 1931 allowed the UK to better manage the economy, enabling the government to adjust the amount of money available to match demand, which is not possible when the money supply is linked to a commodity. Today, the Bank of England manages this stability through an inflation target.

---

The modern money system can be seen as a set of nested IOUs. Currency and deposits (broad money) serve the general public, while reserves (base money) serve the banks, all ultimately resting on the fundamental societal agreement—the trust—that these specific IOUs will be honored and accepted in exchange. The sheer quantity of money today being bank-created deposits, rather than central bank-issued currency, highlights that commercial bank debt, universally trusted, forms the vast majority of money in the modern economy.

Money in the modern economy is defined as a special kind of IOU (a financial asset), and the sources identify three main types of money currently circulating: currency, bank deposits, and central bank reserves. Each type represents a specific IOU, or financial liability, issued by one sector of the economy to another.

The economy is generally split into three main groups: the central bank (like the Bank of England), commercial banks (like high street banks), and consumers (households and companies). The three types of money function as IOUs between these groups.

I. Bank Deposits (The Largest Component)

Bank deposits represent the largest proportion of money held by the public in the modern economy.

1. Definition and Scope: Bank deposits are an IOU from commercial banks to consumers. They are typically held electronically and come in many forms, such as current accounts or savings accounts. As of December 2013, 97% of the money held by the public in the United Kingdom was in the form of deposits with banks, rather than currency.
2. Function and Trust: Consumers prefer holding bank deposits over physical currency because deposits can pay interest and are generally a more convenient medium of exchange and store of value. Deposits are trusted because, for most household depositors, they are guaranteed up to a certain value, ensuring confidence in their convertibility into currency. Consumers use deposits directly as the medium of exchange, such as when paying a shop by debit card.
3. Creation: Unlike currency, bank deposits are mostly created by commercial banks themselves. When a bank issues a new loan to a customer, it simply credits the customer's account with a higher deposit balance, which simultaneously creates new money. The bank's IOU (the deposit) becomes money because it is widely accepted as a medium of exchange.
4. Broad Money: Bank deposits, combined with currency held by the private sector, make up what is known as Broad money.

II. Currency (Fiat Money)

Currency is the physical form of money, consisting of banknotes and coin, but it constitutes a very small amount of the total money held by people and firms in the economy.

1. Definition and Issuer: Currency is an IOU from the central bank, mostly to consumers. Banknotes make up around 94% of the total value of currency (as of December 2013) and are a "promise to pay" the holder a specified sum. These banknotes are recorded as a liability on the central bank's balance sheet and an asset for the holder.
2. Nature (Fiat): Since 1931, Bank of England money has been fiat money. Fiat money is defined as money that is not convertible to any other asset like gold or other commodities. The central bank's debt can only be repaid in more fiat money.
3. Trust and Value: The state generally underpins the use of currency by accepting it for tax payments and by deeming it "legal tender". However, its universal acceptance depends on trust that its value will remain broadly stable over time. The Bank of England achieves this stability by maintaining an inflation target for consumer prices.
4. Creation: The Bank of England issues new banknotes to meet the public's demand, often by swapping new notes for old ones. Commercial banks obtain extra newly issued currency by swapping their central bank reserves for the physical notes.

III. Central Bank Reserves (Base Money)

Central bank reserves are exclusively used by commercial banks for transactions with each other.

1. Definition and Issuer: Reserves are a different type of IOU from the central bank. They are electronic records of the amount owed by the central bank to each commercial bank.
2. Function: Reserves act as a medium of exchange for commercial banks, similar to how current accounts function for households. When one commercial bank needs to make a large payment to another, the Bank of England adjusts their reserve balances accordingly.
3. Relationship to Currency: Commercial banks need reserves to purchase currency from the central bank when meeting depositor demands for withdrawals. The central bank guarantees that reserves can be swapped for currency.
4. Base Money: Central bank reserves, combined with currency (both held by consumers and banks), comprise Base money (or Central bank money). This is important because the central bank uses its position as the sole issuer of base money to implement monetary policy.

In summary, all three types of modern money are special kinds of IOUs that are universally trusted to act as a medium of exchange. The relationship between them shows a hierarchy of debt: bank deposits and currency form Broad money used by the public, while central bank reserves and currency form Base money issued by the central bank, which underpins the system. The fact that bank deposits (commercial bank debt) constitute the vast majority of the money supply means the modern monetary system relies heavily on the public’s confidence in the solvency and liquidity of commercial banks.

The sources define money in the modern economy as a universally trusted financial claim or IOU [1, 3 money in the modern economy as a universally trusted financial claim or IOU. To quantify the amount of this debt circulating, economists and commentators pay close attention to different aggregate measures of money, specifically Broad money and Base money. These measures categorize the three main types of money—currency, bank deposits, and central bank reserves—based on which sector holds them and which sector issued them.

Here is a discussion of the Measures of Money in the context of the modern economy:

I. Broad Money

Broad money is the measure of money most relevant to consumption and spending decisions in the economy.

Composition: Broad money comprises the IOUs held by the private sector of households and companies, referred to as 'consumers'. Specifically, it is made up of:

1. Currency (banknotes and coin) held by the private sector. This is an IOU from the central bank.
2. Bank Deposits (and other similar short-term liabilities of commercial banks) held by consumers. This is an IOU from commercial banks to consumers.

Significance: Broad money is considered a useful concept because it measures the amount of money held by those responsible for spending decisions in the economy (households and companies). Economists and academics pay close attention to the amount of broad money circulating.

Measure Details: The Bank of England's headline measure of broad money is M4ex. This specific measure excludes the deposits of certain financial institutions (known as intermediate other financial corporations or IOFCs) to ensure the measure is more relevant for tracking spending in the economy.

Dominant Component: It is crucial to note that the vast majority of broad money consists of bank deposits. As of December 2013, 97% of the money held by the public in the United Kingdom was in the form of deposits with banks, rather than currency.

II. Base Money (or Central Bank Money)

Base money is the aggregate measure that focuses solely on the liabilities (IOUs) issued by the central bank.

Composition: Base money comprises IOUs from the central bank, specifically:

1. Currency (banknotes and coin). This includes currency held by consumers and currency held by commercial banks in their tills.
2. Central Bank Reserves. These are electronic IOUs from the central bank to commercial banks.

Significance: Base money is important because the central bank uses its position as the only issuer of base money to implement monetary policy. The central bank can vary the interest rate paid on reserves to affect spending and inflation.

Alternative Names: Base money is also known as Monetary base, Central bank money, Outside money (in the UK context), and High-powered money, including the specific measure M0.

III. Relationship Between the Measures

The balance sheets of the three main groups (Central Bank, Commercial Banks, and Consumers) illustrate the relationship between these measures:

• Broad money is the sum of the assets (deposits and currency) held by the Consumers [31, Figure 2].
• Base money is the sum of the central bank's IOUs (reserves and currency), which are assets held by the Commercial Banks and Consumers [31, Figure 2].

The sources emphasize that the total amount of broad money is greater than the amount of base money. This highlights that the majority of the money supply (deposits) is created by commercial banks through the lending process, not directly by the central bank issuing base money.

The sources define money in the modern economy as a special kind of IOU that is universally trusted money in the modern economy as a special kind of IOU that is universally trusted. Money’s universal acceptance is necessary because it fulfills key roles that facilitate exchange and specialization in the economy.

One common way of defining money, which provides the traditional context for its role in the modern economy, is through the three important functions it performs.

I. Medium of Exchange

The medium of exchange is often viewed by economists as the most important function of money.

Definition and Function: Money must be a medium of exchange—something that people hold because they plan to swap it for something else, rather than wanting the item itself.

Role in the Economy:

• Facilitating Trade: Money is essential for moving an economy from a self-sufficient subsistence economy (where people consume only what they produce) to an exchange economy where people specialize in production and trade. In a subsistence economy, like the example of Robinson Crusoe alone on a desert island, money is unnecessary. However, specialization and trade allow people (like Robinson Crusoe and Man Friday) to consume more by focusing on what they are best at producing.
• Overcoming Barter Limitations: While direct swapping (barter) is possible, exchanges in the modern economy are far more complicated due to the large number of people involved and the lack of coincident timing of exchanges. Money, as a universally trusted IOU, solves the problem of a complex web of individual IOUs and the lack of trust inherent in such systems, becoming universally acceptable as the medium of exchange.
• Modern Examples: Bank deposits are increasingly used as the medium of exchange in the modern economy. When a consumer pays a shop by debit card, bank deposits are used directly without conversion to currency.

II. Unit of Account

The unit of account is the standard measure in which goods and services are priced.

Definition and Function: The unit of account is the thing that goods and services are priced in terms of, appearing on menus, contracts, or price labels. In modern economies, the unit of account is usually the national currency, such as the pound in the United Kingdom. Historically, items might have been priced in common goods like "bushels of wheat" or farm animals.

Efficiency Link: It is generally considered efficient for the medium of exchange to also be the unit of account. If items were priced in one currency (e.g., US dollars) but payment was accepted in another (e.g., sterling), customers would constantly have to calculate the exchange rate, which would take time and effort.

III. Store of Value

Money is expected to retain its purchasing power over time.

Definition and Function: The store of value is something that is expected to retain its value in a reasonably predictable way over time. Historically, assets like gold or silver have been good stores of value, unlike perishable food.

Interdependence with Medium of Exchange: The functions are closely linked: an asset is less useful as the medium of exchange if it will not be worth as much tomorrow (i.e., if it is not a good store of value).

• For example, during hyperinflation in countries like Germany after World War I, the local currency became such a poor store of value that people began using foreign currencies as an alternative medium of exchange.
• To ensure sterling retains its usefulness in exchange, the Bank of England's objective is to safeguard the value of the currency, primarily by maintaining an inflation target.
• However, not all good stores of value are good media of exchange; for instance, houses retain value over time but cannot be easily passed around as payment.

Summary of Modern Money Functions

In the context of the modern economy, money, which is mostly bank deposits and fiat currency, performs these three traditional functions. The trust placed in this special IOU is maintained by measures like deposit guarantees and the central bank's commitment to low and stable inflation, ensuring that modern money remains effective as a store of value and thus universally acceptable as a medium of exchange.

The sources discuss **The sources discuss recent developments in payment technologies and alternative currencies as innovations that are related to, but distinct from, the traditional types of money (currency, bank deposits, and central bank reserves) circulating in the modern economy.

In the larger context of money in the modern economy, which is primarily composed of universally trusted IOUs (bank deposits and fiat currency), these innovations generally perform some of the functions of money, but are not typically accepted as a medium of exchange to the same extent as currency, central bank reserves, or bank deposits.

The sources categorize these innovations into three main groups: electronic forms of money (e-money), local currencies, and digital currencies (such as Bitcoin).

I. Electronic Forms of Money (E-Money)

These innovations focus on improving the convenience of making payments using existing money, particularly bank deposits.

• Definition: E-money allows households and businesses to convert their existing bank deposits into purely electronic forms of money.
• Examples: PayPal and Google Wallet are cited as examples of these technologies.
• Functions:
  • Store of Value: E-money serves as a store of value, provided that the companies supplying it are seen as trustworthy.
  • Medium of Exchange: E-money can be used as a medium of exchange with businesses (such as online sellers) or individuals who accept it.
  • Unit of Account: Transactions using these technologies are typically denominated in the existing unit of account (e.g., pounds sterling in the United Kingdom).
• Limitations: While potentially more convenient than banknotes for some transactions, e-money is still not as widely accepted as other media of exchange; for example, it is generally not accepted by high street shops.

II. Local Currencies

Local currencies aim to encourage economic activity within a specific, defined environment.

• Definition: These are complementary currencies, such as the Bristol, Brixton, or Lewes Pounds in the United Kingdom.
• Creation and Exchange: Local currencies are obtained by swapping them for standard currency (e.g., pounds sterling) at fixed rates (e.g., one sterling pound for one Bristol Pound).
• Functions and Limitations:
  • Unit of Account: Local currency can be exchanged for goods and services priced in their own unit of account (e.g., Brixton Pounds rather than sterling pounds).
  • Medium of Exchange: Their use as a medium of exchange is intentionally limited. For instance, the Lewes Pound can only be used at participating retailers located in the Lewes area.
• Supply: The amount of money held in local currencies depends entirely on the demand for them, as they are only put into circulation when exchanged for pounds sterling.

III. Digital Currencies

Digital currencies, such as Bitcoin, Litecoin, and Ripple, represent a further category of innovation.

• Key Difference: Unlike local currencies, the exchange rate between digital currencies and traditional currencies is not fixed.
• Functions and Use:
  • Medium of Exchange: Digital currencies are not at present widely used as a medium of exchange.
  • Asset Class: Their popularity largely stems from their ability to serve as an asset class, suggesting they may have more conceptual similarities to commodities, such as gold, than money.
• Creation and Supply: Digital currencies differ fundamentally from the other technologies mentioned because they can be created out of nothing, although typically at pre-determined rates. Conversely, the supply of digital currencies is usually limited, contrasting with e-money and local currencies, whose amounts depend on demand.

In sum, while innovation is ongoing, the sources indicate that as of the time of publication, none of these alternative payment technologies or currencies have achieved the level of universal trust and acceptance necessary to supplant the established forms of money (bank deposits and currency) as the primary medium of exchange in the modern economy. They function on the periphery, often leveraging the stability and established unit of account provided by the existing monetary system.