Famous quotes

"Happiness can be defined, in part at least, as the fruit of the desire and ability to sacrifice what we want now for what we want eventually" - Stephen Covey

Thursday, February 26, 2026

Why Europe Doesn't Have a Tesla

 

Why Europe doesn’t have a Tesla

Words by Pieter Garicano | 17th February 2026

Europe’s cutting edge firms are falling far behind the American frontier because of restrictive labor laws. In recent decades, Europe has fallen behind the United States; in 2000, incomes in the original six members of the European Union were just 10 percent behind Americans, whereas today they are 20 percent lower. One major factor is a lack of innovation; Europe lacks tech giants like Google, Meta, and Amazon, and has even failed to keep up in industries it traditionally excelled in, such as carmaking. While Tesla is now worth more than the next nine largest carmakers put together and Waymo serves six American cities with robotaxis, Europe’s lack of a "Tesla" is seen as existential.

Common explanations—high energy prices, expensive housing, high taxes, and proceduralism—also apply to California, which still birthed Tesla and Waymo. Furthermore, European governments often spend more on research than the US, and companies like Volkswagen are among the world's top R&D spenders. What truly distinguishes Europe is the cost of labor: relative to income, it costs large companies four times more to lay off French and German workers than American ones, making Americans ten times more likely to be fired in any given year. This makes European businesses exceptionally hesitant to hire unless they are certain they want an employee long-term. Because innovation requires experimentation and risk, and risky jobs are more likely to be discontinued, high severance costs incentivize European firms to stick to "safe," unchanging areas, leading to long-term decline.

Failure costs

Innovation is expensive because failure is expensive. Even in the US, Google spent $2.1 billion laying off 12,000 workers in 2023 (about $175,000 per person). However, US labor law is generally "at-will," with only narrow exceptions for public policy, implied contracts, or good faith. In contrast, most European countries mandate large severance payments; in Germany, a fairly dismissed worker is entitled to 15 days of pay for every year of service.

German employers must also pass a social selection test (Sozialauswahl) for redundancies over ten employees, prioritizing the dismissal of those with the "weakest social claim" based on age, tenure, and family obligations. Dismissing disabled employees requires public office approval, and caregivers cannot be dismissed for two years after notifying their employer. Large companies must also deal with works councils, which can block major decisions. In 2024, Volkswagen’s works council blocked plans to close three factories, leading the company to halt compulsory redundancies until 2030.

In France, restructuring more than ten employees requires regulator approval and a "good faith" attempt to protect jobs, often leading to company-wide hiring freezes. If courts find a lack of "economic justification," they can impose massive fines; Continental was once ordered to pay up to three years of salary to 680 employees. Consequently, companies often "bribe" workers to leave: Amazon offered French employees a year’s salary to quit, and Bayer offered some German workers over four years' worth of pay. Estimates suggest restructuring costs per employee are roughly 7 months of salary in the US, compared to 31 in Germany, 38 in France, 52 in Italy, and 62 in Spain.

Risky business

While employment levels in the Euro area (71%) are now similar to the US (72%), European companies have shifted away from risky areas where layoffs are likely. Innovation requires accepting failure: Apple spent $10 billion on a failed car project, and GM lost $3.4 billion on Cruise in 2023 alone. These failures are the price of successes like Waymo.

For European firms, the downside of a failed bet is much higher. When Audi cancelled its weak-selling Q8 E-Tron and moved to close its Brussels factory, it had to spend €610 million on severance (over €200,000 per employee), which doubled the cost of the closure and exceeded the cost of writing off the factory's assets. Such experiences teach executives to avoid innovation or move it abroad; future Audi electric models will be built in Mexico. Volkswagen similarly ignored electric vehicles for years before a disastrous, multi-billion-dollar attempt to develop software in-house that resulted in 300 bugs a day. Ultimately, VW had to license technology from the American startup Rivian for $5 billion.

This pattern is seen elsewhere: Nokia spent €1.8 billion in 2012 alone on employee termination benefits. High failure costs also explain why European venture capital returns are five points lower than in the US, leading to less investment due to a lack of opportunity rather than a lack of capital.

Keeping small business small

While startups are often exempt from these laws, they face them as soon as they grow. This deters growth and acquisitions; 79% of startup acquisitions between 2012 and 2016 occurred in the US, and European firms made only 7% of acquisitions of American startups. Successful European founders often move their companies to the US or elsewhere to avoid these regulations.

When the rubber leaves the road

The European model excels at incremental innovation. For a century, carmaking involved making existing designs more efficient. A 2025 VW Polo is a third more fuel-efficient than the 1975 original, and European internal combustion engines are "engineering miracles." This system benefits from specialized knowledge and long tenures (the average VW employee is 45). However, it fails at radical innovation, like the shift to electric or autonomous vehicles.

The best of both

Europe can protect workers without stifling innovation by adopting "flexicurity" models.

  • Austria: Uses portable savings accounts for severance.
  • Switzerland: Has no mandatory severance.
  • Denmark: Allows firing almost at-will but provides unemployment insurance covering 90% of income, funded by the government spending 2% of GDP on retraining.

Denmark and Switzerland are Europe’s innovation heavyweights, home to firms like Novo Nordisk and Novartis. Even limited reforms, such as allowing high-earners (above the 90th percentile) to opt out of employment legislation, could make European services competitive.

Europe had Teslas once

Current labor laws are a form of "one-way feudalism" where employees can leave but employers cannot. Yet, Europe once innovated like America. In the 1880s, the French firm De Dion-Bouton invested heavily in steam cars, failed, and discontinued the experiment in 1894. They then tried petrol engines, became the world's largest automaker, and pioneered a key 20th-century invention. Europe has had its "Teslas" before and, with institutional reform, can have them again.

India T20 Record

 Here is India's men's T20 International (T20I) head-to-head record against each opponent team, based on the most consistent and detailed sources (primarily Wikipedia's record by opponent page, cross-referenced with other stats sites like CricIndeed and partial ESPNcricinfo summaries). The data is accurate as of February 2026 (latest match referenced around February 22, 2026, India vs South Africa).


In T20Is, ties are often resolved via super overs (or bowl-outs in older cases), so stats include:

- **Won** / **Lost**: Direct wins/losses.

- **Tie+Win** / **Tie+Loss**: Ties decided by tiebreaker (India has 6 Tie+Win and 0 Tie+Loss).

- **Tied**: Rare untied cases (1 for India).

- **% Won**: Calculated including tiebreakers (wins + tie+wins) / (matches - no results).


### ICC Full Members


- **Afghanistan**: Matches 9, Won 7, Lost 0, Tied 0, Tie+Win 1, Tie+Loss 0, NR 1, Win% ~77.78–88.89 (varies slightly by source calculation), First 2010, Last 2024.

- **Australia**: Matches 37, Won 22, Lost 12, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 3 (or 1 in some), Win% 64.70 (or ~59–64), First 2007, Last 2025.

- **Bangladesh**: Matches 18, Won 17, Lost 1, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 0, Win% 94.44, First 2009, Last 2025.

- **England**: Matches 29, Won 17, Lost 12, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 0, Win% 58.62, First 2007, Last 2025.

- **Ireland**: Matches 8, Won 8, Lost 0, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, First 2009, Last 2024.

- **New Zealand**: Matches 30, Won 16, Lost 11, Tied 1, Tie+Win 2, Tie+Loss 0, NR 0, Win% 61.66 (or ~51–61), First 2007, Last 2026.

- **Pakistan**: Matches 17, Won 13, Lost 3, Tied 0, Tie+Win 1, Tie+Loss 0, NR 0, Win% 79.41 (or ~76–82), First 2007, Last 2026.

- **South Africa**: Matches 36, Won 21, Lost 14, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 1, Win% 60.00 (or ~58), First 2006, Last 2026.

- **Sri Lanka**: Matches 33, Won 21, Lost 9, Tied 0, Tie+Win 2, Tie+Loss 0, NR 1, Win% 63.63 (or ~70), First 2009, Last 2025.

- **West Indies**: Matches 30, Won 19, Lost 10, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 1, Win% 63.33, First 2009, Last 2023.

- **Zimbabwe**: Matches 13, Won 10, Lost 3, Tied 0, Tie+Win 0, Tie+Loss 0, NR 0, Win% 76.92, First 2010, Last 2024.


### ICC Associate Members


- **Hong Kong**: Matches 1, Won 1, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2022.

- **Namibia**: Matches 2, Won 2, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2021–2026.

- **Nepal**: Matches 1, Won 1, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2023.

- **Netherlands**: Matches 2, Won 2, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2022–2026.

- **Oman**: Matches 1, Won 1, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2025.

- **Scotland**: Matches 2, Won 1, Lost 0, NR 1, Win% 50.00, 2007–2021.

- **United Arab Emirates**: Matches 2, Won 2, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2016–2025.

- **United States**: Matches 2, Won 2, Lost 0, NR 0, Win% 100.00, 2024–2026.


### Overall

India has played **273** T20I matches, Won **183**, Lost **75**, Tied **1**, Tie+Win **6**, Tie+Loss **0**, No Result **8**, overall Win% **71.50** (from 2006 to 2026).


India maintains a positive record (win% >50%) against every major opponent they've faced multiple times, with particularly dominant records vs Bangladesh, Ireland, and Afghanistan. For the most precise/latest figures (as cricket stats update frequently), check ESPNcricinfo's team results summary by opposition or Wikipedia's page directly.

Newspaper Summary 270226

 

Compensate content creators: IT Minister to online platforms

GIVES ULTIMATUM. If not done voluntarily, there are legal ways to enforce it: Vaishnaw

Our Bureau New Delhi

Digital platforms must ensure fair revenue share with news publishers and content creators, Union IT Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw said on Thursday. If this is not done voluntarily, there are clear legal pathways, already shown by other countries, to mandate them, he added.

Speaking at the Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA) Conclave 2026, Vaishnaw said, “Platforms must share revenue in a fair way with the people who are creating the content, whether it is news persons, conventional media, creators sitting in far-flung areas, influencers, the professors and researchers who are disseminating their work using the platforms... This is a major concern that the entire society is raising. Everywhere, the principle now has to be set right”.

EQUITABLE SHARE

“I will request all the platforms to rethink your revenue sharing policies. And if this is not done voluntarily, there are so many countries which have shown the path to get it done in a legal way,” the Minister said. News organisations and industry bodies have been raising the issue of equitable revenue share with tech giants for some time now. Several countries, such as Australia and Canada, have either enacted laws, while others have brought in different frameworks that mandate or encourage revenue-sharing arrangements between tech giants and news publishers.

Pointing out that original content had powered society’s growth historically, he cautioned that if intellectual property is not respected and fairly compensated, the growth of society, science, technology, arts and literature will all be stunted. Simultaneously, Vaishnaw stated that platforms must take responsibility for the content hosted by them and proactively take measures to ensure online safety of children and citizens from harmful or misleading content.

He added that every institution is based on the fundamental tenet of trust, which is under threat particularly from deepfakes, disinformation and synthetically generated content using faces and voices of public figures.

CONTENT RESPONSIBILITY

The Minister said platforms are no longer pure intermediaries but hosts which need to take responsibility. “Today, platforms have become powerful media outlets. And like media organisations, platforms must take responsibility for the content that is hosted by them. Non-adherence to these principles will definitely make them responsible because the nature of the internet has changed now".

“Also, synthetic content should not be generated without the consent of the person whose face or voice or personality has been used to create the content. Time has come to make that big inflectional change,” Vaishnaw stated.


NRI deposit inflows fall 16% in FY26 due to weak rupee

Yashaswani Chauhan New Delhi

NRI deposit inflows declined 16 per cent to $11.2 billion during April-December FY26, reversing a sharp 42.8 per cent surge to $13.33 billion in the corresponding period of FY25. The moderation follows two years of strong growth where inflows rose 72.7 per cent in FY24 and 42.8 per cent in FY25, marking a recovery from a 61.1 per cent contraction in FY22.

“Growth in NRI deposits has always been very episodic and inconsistent,” stated Anil Sood of the Institute for Advanced Studies in Complex Choices. He noted that after stabilising around $6 billion annually between 2017-18 and 2022-23, flows rose to $9 billion and $13 billion in the following years. The current reduction may simply be bringing flows back to a normal level of less than $10 billion.

CURRENCY EXPECTATIONS

Vivek Iyer, Partner and Financial Services Risk Advisory Leader at Grant Thornton Bharat, attributed the slowdown to expectations of a weaker rupee amid global geopolitical uncertainties. He described it as a "timing game" to ensure more rupees are received for the same amount of dollars, suggesting the change is tactical rather than structural.

FCNR (B) DEPOSITS

Category-wise data indicates the overall decline was led by FCNR(B) accounts, where inflows dropped sharply by 68.4 per cent year-on-year to $2.04 billion in FY26. These are foreign currency-denominated term deposits that protect investors from exchange rate risks.

In contrast, other categories saw growth:

  • NRE deposits: Grew 41.7 per cent to $5.06 billion in FY26. These rupee-denominated accounts are tax-free and fully repatriable.
  • NRO accounts: Expanded 24.3 per cent to $4.09 billion. These are used for managing income earned in India, such as rent or dividends.

REPATRIABLE SENSITIVITY

Nearly 80 per cent of NRI deposits are held in repatriable accounts (FCNR(B) and NRE), making them highly sensitive to interest rate differentials and currency expectations. Historically, inflows have been supported by macroeconomic stability and higher interest rates, occasionally driven by RBI incentives.

Experts noted that while FCNR(B) deposits are more volatile and yield-sensitive, NRE accounts tend to be more stable, often held by workers with long-term ties to India. During phases of rupee depreciation, NRE accounts become more attractive as they translate into higher rupee returns for the same dollar inflow.

Looking forward, analysts expect flows to stabilise. Sood cautioned that stable flows depend on a stable INR and the RBI maintaining policy rates, noting that rate cuts or further depreciation expectations could deter future deposits.


Japanese auto firms plan green investment in UP

S Ronendra Singh New Delhi

Automobile and auto components companies like Suzuki Motor (SMC), Honda Motor (HMC) and Minda Corporation have offered to invest in Uttar Pradesh towards green mobility and sustainable industrial growth. Senior leadership of these companies met Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath in Japan and discussed future plans. For instance, Yogi met Toshihiro Suzuki, President of SMC, and Hisashi Takeuchi, Managing Director and CEO, Maruti Suzuki India, who proposed a compressed biogas plant.

4 DAY VISIT

As per the State government, during his four-day visit, the Chief Minister held successful investment road shows in Singapore and Japan. In Singapore, the State government received investment proposals worth around ₹1 lakh crore and signed MoUs worth ₹60,000 crore. Similarly, it received investment proposals worth ₹1.5 lakh crore and inked MoUs worth ₹90,000 crore in Japan.

“Discussions focused on Suzuki’s proposed entry into the renewable energy sector through a compressed biogas plant, along with expansion of its supplier ecosystem to strengthen the automotive value chain and generate employment,” Yogi said in a social media post. He apprised the delegation about land parcels available at competitive rates for auto clusters, specifically offering land in the Bundelkhand Industrial Development Authority for renewable energy projects.

HONDA'S UP FOOTPRINT

Similarly, Honda Motor, which has housed its first factory and corporate office in Greater Noida for the last 30 years, stated that 30 per cent of its investment in India had been made in Uttar Pradesh. Though Honda Cars India has discontinued making cars in the Greater Noida factory (moving production to its Tapukara plant in Rajasthan), it still retains its corporate headquarters in Greater Noida.

“Uttar Pradesh is the home of Honda Motor Company in automobiles as well as the byproducts... We see a lot of potential in Uttar Pradesh,” said Noriya Kaihara, Director, Executive Vice President and Representative Executive Officer, HMC.


New GDP series to use 600 item level data

FOCUS ON ACCURACY. The revised series will adopt double deflation for sharper growth estimates

Shishir Sinha New Delhi

The Ministry of Statistics will significantly expand the data used to calculate India’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in the upcoming series with base year 2022-23, aiming to improve the accuracy of growth estimates. The revised series, scheduled for release on Friday, will use nearly 600 item level data indicators under the double deflation method, more than three times the current 180 level data used for price adjustment.

NEW GROWTH DATA

A senior official said once the national GDP numbers under the new base year are released, work will begin on compiling revised growth data for States and Union Territories.

At the heart of the revision is the shift to full adoption of the double deflation method for key sectors such as manufacturing and agriculture and the complete elimination of the single deflation method. Under this approach, the value of output and the cost of inputs are adjusted separately for price changes before calculating real growth. Previously, India used a mix of single and double deflation; the new series expects to make GDP estimates more robust and internationally aligned.

BROADER PRICE BASE

Statisticians will now track a much wider basket of goods and services to strip out inflation effects. While the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) will continue as the main deflator until its own base year is updated, the expansion to 600 item level indicators will improve the reliability of real growth numbers, especially in sectors where input costs fluctuate differently from output prices.

SURVEY-BASED DATA

The new series will rely more heavily on administrative and survey-based data rather than proxy estimates. Key changes include:

  • Household sector estimates: Now based on actual annual surveys like the Annual Survey of Unincorporated Sector Enterprises (ASUSE) and the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS).
  • GST data: Used extensively to allocate private corporate sector output across States and cross-verify estimates.
  • E-Vahan data: Will help estimate household spending on road transport services.
  • Public Finance Management System (PFMS): Data will be used to compile Central government expenditure and distribute it across States.

CHANGES AFOOT

  • Annual quarterly estimates for 2022-23 to 2025-26 are to be released on Friday.
  • Back series data are expected by December 2026.
  • The revised series is in sync with international statistical standards.
  • Major methodological improvements include a reduction in allocation-based methods in favor of direct estimation for some sectors and a reduction in reliance on fixed ratios and proxies.

Securities Bill has a problematic Section

ANTI-MARKET. An omnibus exemption for public sector companies from governance norms risks weakening accountability and competitive neutrality

MS SAHOO & CKG NAIR

The Securities Market Code Bill, 2025 is a significant attempt to modernize India’s securities law architecture, yet Section 65(2) risks diluting the reformist ethos the Bill otherwise seeks to advance. This specific section empowers the Centre, in the "public interest," to exempt any listed public sector company (PSC) from any or all requirements relating to capital issues, corporate governance, disclosures, takeover regulations, and public shareholding norms. In effect, it enables the executive to suspend core market disciplines for an entire ownership class, striking at the philosophical core of India’s post-1991 economic reforms.

SHORT SHRIFT TO NEUTRALITY

A central pillar of Indian economic reform has been competitive neutrality, where public and private enterprises in the same market are subject to the same laws and governance expectations. Section 65(2) departs from this logic by creating a dual regime where private companies remain bound by strict norms while listed PSCs may be relieved from them through executive notification. This disturbs the level playing field and injects uncertainty into regulatory expectations.

Furthermore, the provision creates an anomalous relationship between market access and market discipline. While listed PSCs benefit from attracting institutional investors and market valuation to support disinvestment, they may now be exempted from the very rules—such as public float requirements and takeover protections—that underpin investor confidence. To enjoy market benefits without being subject to its discipline is to create "regulatory free riders," which can irretrievably weaken long-term confidence in the system.

REGULATORY AUTONOMY

The justification of "public interest" cannot be presumed solely based on state ownership, especially when listed PSCs compete directly with private firms in sectors like banking, energy, and infrastructure. If a public sector steel company and a private peer access the same capital market, the rationale for differential compliance becomes difficult to sustain.

Independent securities regulation evolved to ensure rule-making remains stable and insulated from short-term pressures. The prospect of selective exemptions may unsettle the perception of global institutional investors who value consistency. Moreover, there is little evidence that regulatory relaxation enhances enterprise value; markets consistently reward governance quality, board independence, and credible minority shareholder protection.

NEED FOR SAFEGUARDS

Minority shareholders in PSCs, including retail investors and pension funds, rely on these standards for protection. When the state acts as both the controlling shareholder and the rule-maker, these safeguards assume even greater significance.

The Bill presents an opportunity to reinforce India’s commitment to competitive neutrality. If public enterprises seek capital from public markets, they must accept the accompanying discipline. Ownership itself should not be the basis for differential treatment; instead, genuine sector-specific challenges should be addressed through transparent consultation or targeted legislative changes applicable to all similarly situated entities.


Sahoo is former Chairperson, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India; Nair is former Director, National Institute of Securities Markets.


The large US public debt, and the way forward

MONEY MATTERS. More than financing fiscal deficits, the solution lies in cutting them

GURBACHAN SINGH

The tariffs in the US have been repeatedly in the news, and understandably so. However, there is another very important issue which is, in the process, getting much less attention. This is the very large US public debt, which now stands at about 120 per cent of the GDP. The interest payments on the public debt now exceed the military spending. The international reserve currency status for the US is increasingly in question; the sell-off of US government securities by China over time is just one prominent example. How is the US handling the whole situation?

For a clear understanding, we need to first go back in time. In the aftermath of the Global Financial Crisis in 2007, the US public debt rose substantially. However, the interest cost was low for a long time. This is because the Fed used quantitative easing. The so-called base money expanded massively and the Fed bought government securities on a large scale. Most of the additional base money issued by the Fed was, in turn, held by the banks as reserves. The Fed started paying interest on reserve balances in October 2008, which made reserves relatively attractive and helped finance fiscal deficits.

THE LCR MANDATE

In 2015, the liquidity coverage ratio (LCR) was initiated and it was in force fully by 2019. The banks needed to hold high quality liquid assets. Basically, banks are required to hold a good amount of US government securities directly, or indirectly through their holdings of reserves with the Fed. The latter, in turn, holds government securities. Though the LCR requirement is a prudential norm, this too has helped in financing the fiscal deficits.

It is true that the high quality liquid assets actually held by banks are, in any case, significantly more than the requirement. Nevertheless, the regulation matters because the assets held for this reason are effectively illiquid in the normal course of banking! So, additional reserves and government securities are needed for normal banking. This is partly the reason for “excess” liquid assets with banks; the other reason was that the credit off-take was not strong for many years.

Completing the story on base money, though this expanded massively, the time path of money in circulation with the public hardly changed till the time of the Covid-19 crisis. Relatedly, the time path of bank deposits did not rise for a long time. On the assets side, the time path of bank loans was at a lower level, given that banks held large reserves. This is consistent with the relatively low growth of GDP for many years. Though the banks’ direct and indirect holdings of the US public debt are not massive, they are large enough to provide confidence at the margin to the other main buyers. The prices of US government securities did not fall substantially and consistently, which is to say that the yields did not jump even though the debt was large. This contributed synthetically in meeting the sustainability condition for public debt.

After the crisis due to Covid-19 showed up, conditions changed. Though the interest rates fell further for a while, there was soon good economic recovery. Relatedly, the interest rates rose and so did the interest burden on the existing debt. Moreover, the additional debt was very large—the treasury sent cheques to its citizens.

SITUATION DETERIORATING

Overall, the situation on the US debt front and its financing has been deteriorating. The voluntary demand for reserves by banks is softening, which is to say that their indirect demand for the US government securities has been weakening. Again related, the Fed had been moving for some time to quantitative tightening, which is a reversal of quantitative easing. Also, the treasury may be now somewhat increasing the fiscal deficit with its recent Big Beautiful Bill.

It is true that some new positive developments too have been happening for the financing of the public debt. The mortgaged-backed securities that have been held by the Fed are maturing, and some reinvestment is being done in the US government securities. Also, there are new buyers of government securities like the companies that issue Stablecoin. The GENIUS Act, 2025 helped here though the amount reached so far is small. The quantitative tightening has now been stopped by the Fed. The US leadership may do more to manage the situation.

It may exercise various selling or licensing rights, and even use its gold reserves. And, the high inflation seen over the period 2021-23 may happen yet again in future. This could again help in eroding a part of the real debt through the non-transparent ‘inflation tax’. It has helped that hedge funds are now holding a good amount of the long-term US government securities, but we have derivatives and short-term financing, which have their own fragility issues. Relatively more stable, the Fed uses ‘reserve management’ and the treasury intervenes now and then to deal with some frictions.

The point is that the focus has been, by and large, on financing the fiscal deficits. However, the basic policy solution lies in cutting down the fiscal deficits. This can be done in two ways: the treasury needs to cut public spending on some fronts, and it can raise the tax revenues, given that the tax-GDP ratio is low compared to many other developed countries. Otherwise, the debt is very hard to sustain without serious adverse implications. There is scope for course correction—more so when the US has a strong and innovative economy. But it is not clear if the correction is happening anytime soon.


The writer is an independent economist. He taught at Ashoka University, ISI (Delhi) and JNU.


Gift City goes global: Cyprus’ EllinasFin to be first overseas equity to list on NSE IX

DUAL LISTING. Positioned as a test case for such cross-border capital flows through IFSC

BILATERAL AGREEMENT. The development follows the MoU signed in June 2025 between NSE IX and the Cyprus Stock Exchange during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit

Avinash Nair Ahmedabad

In a milestone for Gift City’s evolving offshore capital markets, Cyprus-based financial services company Ellinas Finance will soon list its equity shares on the NSE International Exchange (NSE IX), marking what exchange officials describe as the first cross-border equity listing between India and Cyprus.

“This is the first cross-listing in Gift City,” said V Balasubramaniam, MD and CEO of NSE IX. He told businessline that the Cyprus-listed company will debut on NSE IX next week. “We are going through the listing documents. We are expecting to complete the listing in the next one week,” he added.

Echoing the significance, Viraj Kulkarni, Honorary Consul of the Republic of Cyprus in Mumbai, while speaking at the Global Securities Markets Conclave 2.0 in Gift City on Thursday, said, “This in effect is the culmination of the MoU signed and announced last June in Nicosia by the leaders of both the countries”.

Already listed on the Cyprus Stock Exchange (CSE), Ellinas Finance will now have its equity shares admitted for listing on the NSE IX at Gift City, creating a dual listing structure that allows the company’s shares to be listed on two separate exchanges in different jurisdictions. The Ellinas Finance listing is being positioned as a test case for such cross-border capital flows through India’s International Financial Services Centre (IFSC).

The development follows the MoU signed between NSE IX and the CSE during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Cyprus. The agreement laid the groundwork for cooperation on cross and dual listings, joint product development, research collaboration, fintech engagement, and investor access to a wider pool of financial instruments.

According to the CSE, Ellinas Finance is currently headed by Chairman Demetris Petrides. The main activities of the company, founded in 1992, include providing short- and medium-term lending to individuals and companies through specially-tailored personal and business loans, financing of investor accounts, factoring services, and private equity, among others.

“Cyprus currently holds the presidency of the Council of the European Union. Last year, it was the second-fastest growing country by GDP in Europe. Cyprus ranks among the top 10 countries from which FDI comes to India — a total of $15.3 billion and in the last six months $1.5 billion has been committed,” Kulkarni added.

OTHER PACTS

On Thursday, the Taiwan Stock Exchange signed bilateral MoUs with NSE IX and India INX stock exchanges in Gift City. “The MoU with Taiwan Stock Exchange is more exploratory in nature. Taiwan has a number of larger semiconductor firms whose subsidiaries have operations in India. We are exploring to see if some of them can get listed here,” Balasubramaniam said.

A similar MoU was signed between Afrinex, Mauritius and NSE IX. Afrinex is a Pan-African financial exchange headquartered in Mauritius, established to operate as a multi-currency, multi-asset securities exchange serving investors and issuers across Africa and beyond.


‘Luxembourg facilitates European, global investments into India’

Gilles Roth, Minister of Finance, Luxembourg

Avinash Nair Ahmedabad

Positioning itself as a gateway for European and global capital into India, Luxembourg on Thursday outlined a five-point roadmap to deepen financial cooperation. Speaking at the Global Securities Markets Conclave 2.0 in Gift City, Gilles Roth, Minister of Finance, Luxembourg, stated, “This is a historic opportunity to work with India and we should seize this opportunity. India’s market and growth story is remarkable”.

STRATEGIC COOPERATION

Roth noted that an EU-India trade deal would represent a “strategic step forward,” increasing business predictability, deepening investment links, and creating more structured economic cooperation. He emphasized that such a deal would lead to “fewer frictions and more confidence and more incentives to build long-term partnerships”. As India’s capital markets expand and funding needs rise, Luxembourg positioned itself as a platform to channel international capital into the country.

“Luxembourg is a cross-border financial centre by design. We specialise in building bridges between countries, investor bases and real economy needs,” Roth said. He highlighted that Luxembourg hosts around €8 trillion in assets under management, distributes funds in over 80 countries, and represents approximately 60 per cent of global cross-border fund distribution.

The Minister identified two primary options for cooperation:

  • Supporting Indian institutions seeking European and global investors through Luxembourg structures and platforms.
  • Facilitating European and global investments into India.

5-POINT PLAN

Roth outlined a specific five-point framework designed to deepen financial integration between the two nations:

  1. Investment Connectivity: Focusing on investment fund and asset management connectivity.
  2. Reducing Friction: Centering on reducing friction for high-quality issuers and investors, including facilitating sustainable listings and improving market access mechanisms.
  3. Institutional Capital: Channeling European institutional capital into India’s large investment requirements by making projects “investable, transparent and scalable”.
  4. Digitalisation: Targeting collaboration in the digitalisation of financial markets, including tokenisation and the use of AI in capital market infrastructure.
  5. Policy Dialogue: Calling for a more structured and operational policy dialogue aimed at strengthening regulatory cooperation and making frameworks more effective for cross-border market participants.

Slack demand, competition weigh on onion exports

ERODING SHARE. Bangladesh and Saudi Arabia cut imports from India, while Pakistan gains on price edge; currency advantage boosts rival suppliers

Vishwanath Kulkarni Bengaluru

India’s onion exports have come under further pressure this financial year, reflecting a sustained decline driven by changing global market dynamics. Shipments have slowed primarily due to reduced off-take from key buyers such as Bangladesh and Saudi Arabia, as these countries increasingly rely on their own domestic production, according to exporters.

POLICY IMPACT

This structural shift in demand has curtailed shipment volumes even as competitive pressures weigh on exports. The weaker currency of Pakistan, a major competing origin, has enhanced its price competitiveness in international markets, making it more difficult for Indian exporters to defend market share, particularly in price-sensitive destinations.

“Demand is there, but we have lost some markets," said Ajit Shah, President, Horticulture Exporters Association. "Bangladesh, one of the biggest buyer, is not buying from us. Lot of countries have developed their own crop; now even Saudi, a good buyer, is not buying”. He added that an Indian export ban imposed 2-3 years ago caused traditional buyers to shift to other suppliers like Pakistan, Sudan, and Yemen.

Earlier, these competing countries exported in small quantities for only 2-3 months a year, but they are now exporting for 6-7 or even nine months annually. Shah noted that while Indian onion quality remains superior, every market is now price-sensitive, leading to a decrease in India's share of demand.

According to DGCIS data, India’s onion exports during April-December of the current financial year registered a 22 per cent decline in value terms at $298.69 million compared to $380.08 million in the corresponding period last year due to lower prices.

VOLUMES UP

Despite the value decline, shipment volumes during this period were up 37 per cent at 11.33 lakh tonnes, compared to 8.26 lakh tonnes the previous year. Onion shipments have generally trended downward in recent years following a ban from December 2023 to March 2024, though all restrictions were removed by March 2025 as supplies improved.

Shah further explained that when Bangladesh lacks its own crop, it now buys maximum quantities from Pakistan, while Saudi Arabia is purchasing from Yemen and Sudan.

“Our prices are similar or up by say $10-50 per tonne, when compared with onions from Sudan or Yemen," Shah stated. "However, we are expensive in comparison with Pakistan as there is a vast difference in their dollar rate and our rate. Our dollar-rupee rate is 90.5, while their dollar to Pakistan rupee rate is 280". This weaker currency gives rival suppliers a significant edge. Currently, Indian exports continue to destinations like Sri Lanka and West Asian countries.

RABI ARRIVALS

Trade sources indicated that prices have eased in recent weeks with improving arrivals. Per Agmarknet data, modal prices are hovering between ₹775-1,500 per quintal in Maharashtra, the major producing State. All-India average wholesale mandi prices eased from ₹1,410.44 per quintal on February 17 to ₹1,085.64 on February 24. Shah noted that the upcoming rabi onion crop is expected to be bigger than last year.

Newspaper Summary 260226

 India’s solar manufacturers unfazed by US’ 126% tariff

SUNNY OUTLOOK. Firms are confident of domestic demand, supply chain diversification

M Ramesh, Chennai

The US Department of Commerce has announced a steep 125.8 per cent countervailing duty on solar cells and modules imported from India, Indonesia, and Laos as a preliminary measure pending a final determination. Indian manufacturers have, however, shrugged off the move, broadly stating they have other business options.

Market Reaction and Allegations Despite the manufacturers' confidence, the US move sent shock waves through renewable energy stocks, with shares of Waaree Energies and Premier Energies dropping sharply. The US action followed a petition by the Alliance for American Solar Manufacturing and Trade, which alleged “unfair” market-distorting subsidies were provided to Indian manufacturers. A final determination on the matter is expected on July 6.

The Alliance stated its petition aimed to halt “ongoing pattern of market-distorting and anti-competitive practices”. It further alleged that after South-East Asian dumping was addressed, some Chinese-backed firms shifted operations to Laos and Indonesia, with companies in India joining in to undercut American producers.

Strategic Alternatives The National Solar Energy Federation of India remains optimistic, noting that a trade deal with the US is being fine-tuned and could supersede these duties. Federation CEO Subrahmanyam Pulipaka highlighted that the government has already initiated a process allowing solar units in Special Economic Zones (SEZs) to sell products in the Domestic Tariff Area (DTA), calling it a “robust alternative”.

Individual firms have also expressed resilience:

  • Vikram Solar: Chairman Gyanesh Chaudhary stated the company can sell in the US from other geographies thanks to a diversified supply chain, while its growth strategy remains “firmly anchored in India”.
  • Premier Energies: The company reported “no material impact” because it had already reduced its exports to “almost nil”.
  • Emmvee Photovoltaics: Stated the duties would have “no impact” as its business is primarily aligned with domestic demand.

Vinay Rustagi, Chief Business Officer, noted that manufacturers have had a long time to refine their sales strategies since the US investigation began in August 2025.

Import Data According to the US Department of Commerce, solar imports from India reached 2.3 GW in 2024, valued at $792.64 million. This is a significant increase from 2022, when imports from India were valued at just $84 million. Overall, the US imported 56 GW of modules and 13.8 GW of cells in 2024, with a total import value of $15.2 billion.


No plan to extend deadline on SIM-binding rules, says Scindia

ADHERENCE TO RULING. On AGR issues raised by Airtel, Minister said the government is abiding by SC’s verdict

S Ronendra Singh, New Delhi

The government on Wednesday asserted that there would be no extension of the deadline for implementing SIM-binding norms for over-the-top (OTT) communication platforms such as WhatsApp, Sharechat, Jiochat, Signal, Meta, and Telegram.

Security Measures Telecom Minister Jyotiraditya Scindia stated, “On national security issues, there can be no compromise. On revenue implication issues, I am very clear in terms of the mandate and where our responsibility lies... Users will have to log out in six hours”.

The Department of Telecommunications (DoT) mandated in November 2025 that OTT platforms must implement continuous SIM-binding, requiring apps to remain strictly linked to an active, physical SIM card in the device. Furthermore, web and desktop versions must automatically log users out every six hours to force fresh re-authentication. The government maintains these steps are essential to prevent remote account hijacking and “digital arrest” scams.

Satellite and Telecom Dues Regarding the allocation of satellite spectrum to Starlink, Scindia noted the government is eager to begin services but emphasized that companies must first comply with security regulations and the government must finalize spectrum assignment pricing.

On the issue of Bharti Airtel's request for relief on adjusted gross revenue (AGR) dues, the Minister ruled out executive intervention. He suggested the carrier pursue legal recourse, stating, “We are operating under a verdict of the Supreme Court. As far as AGR is concerned, it is based on that verdict that we have taken whatever action”.

Background on Repayment The Cabinet had previously approved Vodafone Idea’s AGR dues at ₹87,695 crore on December 31, 2025, featuring a staggered 10-year repayment plan from FY32 to FY41. The DoT has also initiated a reassessment of that company's liabilities for the FY07-FY19 period following Supreme Court rulings that allowed for recalculation.


Outward remittances under LRS dip for 2nd straight year in FY26

DATA FOCUS. Consumption-linked flows register broad-based decline, while asset allocation abroad sees a surge

Yashaswani Chauhan, New Delhi

Outward remittances under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS) have declined for the second consecutive year. In FY26 (April to December), they fell by 4.1 per cent to $21.37 billion from $22.28 billion a year ago. This follows a sharper 10.1 per cent contraction in FY25, after remittances had peaked at $24.8 billion in FY24.

Economists attribute this moderation to a combination of cyclical pressures and structural shifts in flow composition after a strong post-pandemic surge. Anil Sood of the Institute for Advanced Studies in Complex Choices (IASCC) noted that stagnant returns in Indian financial markets and high net-worth individuals moving to low-tax jurisdictions are driving structural shifts toward overseas property and financial assets.

Decisive Tilt Toward Assets While overall flows declined, there was a significant shift toward asset allocation abroad:

  • Immovable Property: Remittances surged 77.2 per cent to $0.38 billion.
  • Equity and Debt: Investment rose 58.6 per cent to $1.77 billion.
  • Deposits: Increased by 11.6 per cent.

In contrast, consumption-linked categories saw broad declines. Travel, the largest component, fell 5.5 per cent to $12.38 billion. Maintenance of close relatives dropped by 5 per cent, gifts by 13.5 per cent, and medical treatment by 34.3 per cent.

Education and Discretionary Spending Remittances for studies abroad fell sharply by 22.3 per cent to $1.72 billion. Sood described this as a likely cyclical decline fueled by rupee depreciation, changes in international immigration policies, and employment uncertainties. However, he suggested immigration regimes might become more supportive as demand for skilled talent clarifies over the next few years.

The drop in travel and discretionary spending reflects wider uncertainty regarding professional employment in high-paying sectors.

Future Outlook Analysts expect investment-related remittances to remain resilient, while growth in consumption-related flows may remain stagnant. Future trajectories could be influenced by policy; the RBI and the government may discourage outward remittances if the rupee remains under pressure or trade performance fails to improve.


The changing face of the factory

What distinguishes advanced factories is process discipline, continuous improvement, digital connectivity and data-driven intelligence

INDUSTRY PUSH. India’s aim to raise manufacturing’s share to 25% of GDP will depend on the design of factories and the people who run them

VIPIN SONDHI G SUNDARARAMAN

For decades, manufacturing in India has struggled with a perception problem; one that affects career choices, productivity growth, export competitiveness and long-term economic resilience. For many young people and often their parents, it still evokes images of repetitive shop-floor work and limited mobility. That perception, shaped by legacy experience and the rise of services, no longer reflects operational reality.

Across the world and increasingly in India, factories are evolving into technology-rich environments where decisions are data-driven, problems are addressed systematically and value is created through design, intelligence and operational leadership at scale. The shift is less about technological spectacle and more about raising productivity through disciplined systems and execution. Factories of the future are not about robots replacing people but about amplifying human capability through technology. This is an evolution visible to anyone who has watched a modern plant floor shift from manual supervision to data-led decision-making.

The recently concluded AI Summit underscored a shift in India’s technology discourse; from experimentation with artificial intelligence to its application in core economic sectors. While attention often gravitates toward consumer-facing AI tools, its more durable impact may lie in manufacturing, where data-driven systems can enhance reliability, optimise processes and raise productivity at scale. The real measure of AI’s promise may not be novelty, but whether it strengthens the competitiveness of India’s industrial base.

FUTURE FACTORIES Factories of the future are often labelled ‘smart factories’, a phrase that reduces them to automation and artificial intelligence. Technology is central, but not the defining feature. What distinguishes advanced factories is process discipline, continuous improvement, digital connectivity and data-driven intelligence. Technology enables performance, while organisational culture and execution discipline sustain it. Those who have led plants through disruption will recognise how quickly sophisticated equipment can underperform without operating rigour.

Plants that layer automation onto weak foundations rarely achieve durable gains, while those with strong operating systems compound advantage when technology is introduced. In this sense, factories of the future are organisational systems as much as technical ones. Modern manufacturing spans products, plant design and supply chains. Mechanical products increasingly integrate electronics and software, making design-for-manufacture inseparable from digital simulation and validation. Factories are designed virtually before capital is deployed, using digital twins to optimise layouts, throughput and energy use.

Artificial intelligence is embedded in these systems powering predictive maintenance, dynamic quality control and real-time process optimisation. In production environments, AI translates data into measurable productivity gains rather than abstract insight. It is less a standalone technology than an enabler of ‘learning factories’, systems that adapt and improve with each production cycle. Supply chains, once treated as support functions, are now strategic assets shaped by real-time visibility and predictive planning, particularly amid geopolitical volatility. On the shop floor, computer vision, predictive maintenance and digital dashboards are replacing manual inspection and reporting. The objective is not output alone, but simultaneous improvement in yield, reliability and responsiveness.

CHANGING LEADERSHIP As factories evolve, so do roles. Operators and engineers increasingly use structured problem-solving tools and digital systems. Supervisors rely on live performance metrics rather than retrospective reports. Leadership requires balancing cost, quality, delivery, safety and sustainability under constraint. Systems thinking and cross-functional coordination become core managerial capabilities.

India’s ambition to raise manufacturing’s share of GDP from around 15-16 per cent to 25 per cent reflects an economic and strategic imperative. It is central to employment creation, economic resilience and India’s negotiating leverage in a fragmented global economy. Achieving this shift will depend less on capacity alone and more on how factories are designed, run and continuously improved; and that makes young people central to the effort.

Manufacturing today accounts for roughly one-sixth of India’s output, compared with over 25 per cent in several East Asian export-led economies. The debate is often framed as manufacturing versus services. The more relevant distinction is between economies that build high-productivity systems and those that assemble capacity without institutional depth. In a capital-scarce environment, the return on manufacturing investment will matter as much as the scale of new capacity. Policy initiatives from PLIs across electronics, automotive and pharmaceuticals to renewed emphasis on defence manufacturing seek to strengthen domestic capability while integrating India more deeply into global value chains. The objective is to become more atmanirbhar while remaining globally connected and competitive.

Beyond automobiles and electronics, several other sectors in India are quietly becoming laboratories for factories of the future. Aerospace and defence manufacturing are advancing in precision machining, digital quality systems and secure supply chains. Pharmaceuticals and medical devices are integrating automation and data integrity to meet global regulatory standards. Renewable energy equipment demands tightly controlled processes and rapid scale-up. India’s growing export orientation will reinforce this shift.

This transition will however not be frictionless. Many firms, particularly MSMEs, face constraints in capital, digital capability and managerial bandwidth. Raising manufacturing’s share of GDP will therefore require investments in skilling, supplier development and institutional strengthening. Productivity gains will ultimately depend on managerial and technical depth within firms.

Manufacturing offers immediate feedback from reality, something every plant leader encounters sooner or later. Production shortfalls, quality defects and safety incidents demand resolution. This makes factories powerful leadership training grounds, requiring individuals to translate strategy into execution and manage trade-offs in high-stakes environments. Factories of the future reinforce this through decentralised problem-solving and disciplined continuous improvement. Leadership emerges from the ability to learn, influence and deliver results.

The factories of the past demanded compliance. The factories of the future will demand creativity, systems thinking and leadership. In building globally competitive factories, India will strengthen not only industrial output but also its economic resilience and bargaining power. As it did for the West, sustained industrial capability will ultimately underwrite our national confidence and strategic voice as we march to 2047.

Sondhi is former MD & CEO of Ashok Leyland and JCB India; Sundararaman is Chief Scientist and Head of Wipro Research. Views are personal.


Seeding farms with tech

AGRISTACK. Provides farmers with an integrated digital profile

AgriStack is re-coding the future of farming in India

Omprakash Subbarao

Indian agriculture is going through a critical and transformative period. Traditionally, farmers made decisions on how to farm based on their past experiences and the changing seasons. This way of farming has been replaced by an increase in precision, electronically-based, and data-driven farming decisions. The new technology available to farmers is AgriStack, which will allow for better delivery of services, money and knowledge by creating a new type of Digital Public Infrastructure that focuses on farmers so they can improve the way they do things in rural India.

DIGITAL PROFILE

AgriStack provides farmers with an integrated and trustworthy digital profile, which alleviates the historically disorganised nature of land and beneficiary data. By creating this trusted base of data, AgriStack provides farmers with easy access to subsidies, credit, crop insurance, and advisory services. As a result, over 8.4 crore farmers are accessing money directly from their digital accounts, reducing corruption and increasing transparency. Therefore, not only does AgriStack improve administrative efficiencies, but also creates enhanced financial inclusion and greater trust in institutions.

Productivity, not welfare delivery, will be the defining change. Farmers adopt farm management practices based on artificial intelligence, satellite-based remote sensing, and precise geolocation soil analysis. These help reduce input expenses, protect and retain the quality of soil, conserve water, grow more food per acre, and preserve resources in an environment of increased climate variability.

The management of both pests and diseases is changing — from reactive to being proactive. Through the use of AI-based diagnostic tools, farmers can utilise mobile devices to identify the early signs of pest or nutrient stress. Additionally, alerts provide farmers with timely information to help them provide precise treatment to their crops to minimise damage and use fewer chemicals than otherwise necessary.

Smallholder farmers experience decreased financial risk as a result of these changes and will be more resilient due to the improved management of their crops.

Also key in terms of innovative development is its decentralisation. New innovation hubs in Tier 2 and Tier 3 areas are creating locally appropriate, affordable technologies that are tailored to both small landholdings as well as to many diverse agro-climatic zones. The bottom-up model of innovation development helps ensure digital transformation is both inclusive and adaptable rather than uniform and from the top down.

Research organisations are linking cutting edge science with agricultural realities. Examples like the GRAMA project by IISc or the Agri Vaahan platform show that AI can help farmers by assisting with crop decision-making, price forecasting, and creating market access. Making these tools available to Farmer Producer Organisations (FPOs) and researchers allows the decentralised collaborative intelligence ecosystem to develop through the use of data to help the whole group grow. A growing number of predictive models are being developed by combining genomic research, soil health records and weather data so that seeds can be developed to withstand changing conditions and crop strategies can be adapted for long-term sustainability.

Training rural youth in areas such as drone operation, data analytics, and climate-smart agronomy will produce a new class of agri-entrepreneurs that can support and grow the use of digital agriculture within their communities.

The AgriStack framework is based on the concept of consent-based data governance. The protection of farmers’ sovereign control over their data will enable agricultural innovation that will guide India’s transition to a more resilient and equitable rural economy.

The writer is Chief Executive, FSID CORE, IISc


Housing Price Index up 1.2% driven by major cities

Our Bureau, Mumbai

The All India House Price Index (HPI) rose to 115.6 in Q3 (October-December) FY26, up from 114.2 in the previous quarter, reflecting a growth of 1.2 per cent. According to a statement from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), this increase was driven by a rise in housing prices across major cities such as Jaipur, Kanpur, and Chennai.

The HPI is compiled based on transaction-level data obtained from registration authorities in 18 cities.

Year-on-Year Growth On a year-on-year basis, the All India HPI grew by 3.6 per cent in Q3 FY26. This represents a moderation compared to the 6.9 per cent growth recorded in the same quarter of the previous year. The RBI noted that cities such as Nagpur, Chandigarh, and Jaipur were primary drivers of this year-on-year growth.

Index Expansion In the first quarter, the index was expanded to include eight additional cities: Hyderabad, Thiruvananthapuram, Pune, Ghaziabad, Thane, Gautam Buddha Nagar, Chandigarh, and Nagpur. This new series uses 2022-23 as the base year.


Tuesday, February 24, 2026

Newspaper Summary 250226

Claude shock: IBM rout sinks Nifty IT

Sanjana B Bengaluru

Shares of IBM tumbled over 13 per cent on Monday, wiping out more than $30 billion in market capitalisation and dragging Indian IT stocks lower, after a blog post by Anthropic stoked investor concerns that AI-led tools like Claude Code could accelerate COBOL modernisation.

The decline weighed heavily on Indian IT stocks, with the Nifty IT index dropping nearly 5 per cent on Tuesday. Individual stock performances saw LTIMindtree fall 6.43 per cent, Tech Mahindra decline 6.17 per cent, and HCLTech slip 5.83 per cent, while industry giants Infosys and TCS both ended down 3.56 per cent.

ANTHROPIC EFFECT

Analysts attributed the aggressive sell-off to an Anthropic blog post highlighting the fragility of legacy COBOL (Common Business-Oriented Language) systems. Anthropic noted that hundreds of billions of lines of this decades-old, poorly documented code still power critical infrastructure, even as the pool of qualified engineers shrinks.

Traditionally, modernising these systems required massive costs, large consulting teams, and multi-year timelines. Anthropic argued that AI tools like Claude Code can compress these cycles from years to just quarters.

Responding to a businessline e-mail, IBM stated: “IBM has been investing in code modernisation for years... Translating COBOL is the easy part. The real work is data architecture redesign, runtime replacement, transaction processing integrity and hardware-accelerated performance built over decades of tight software and hardware coupling". IBM emphasized that AI is the most powerful tool they have ever had to solve these fundamental engineering challenges.

Pareekh Jain, Founder and CEO of EIIR Trend, suggested that while the market sell-off may be an overreaction, the underlying risk is real. He noted that the prospect of AI completing work in as little as two weeks threatens traditional effort-based billing models used by the IT services industry.


Banks up scrutiny of large-value branch transactions post IDFC First Bank scam

Piyush Shukla Mumbai

Lenders have stepped up the scrutiny of high-value, cheque-based transactions generated by branches, after IDFC First Bank reported a material ₹590 crore fraud from its Chandigarh branch last week, senior bankers say.

“We plan to put in an explicit system for high-value transactions. For branch-based transactions exceeding a threshold, we will require explicit confirmation via a verified digital channel or app. We will also use AI. Currently, a branch manager physically clears cheques, but we will implement a system where AI performs initial checking, followed by human confirmation, to better handle exceptions. This was a physical, manual cheque fraud — the most traditional type. We will improvise and put new controls in place,” said V Vaidyanathan, MD and CEO, IDFC First Bank.

A senior private sector banker said that following the IDFC First Bank disclosure, all banks are reviewing their internal controls, especially for high-value transactions.

“At the branch level, we are reviewing and upgrading maker-checker system, scrutinising repeat transactions extensively and adding various layers of authentication, apart from a confirmation call to ensure authenticity of transaction,” the banker said.

INDUSTRY IMPACT

Sources said the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is understood to be satisfied with the IDFC First Bank management’s prompt disclosures and corrective actions post the occurrence of the fraud, and the central bank is unlikely to bring in any policy change for branch-led operation.

The regulator, however, may engage with the bank bilaterally to identify gaps and the persons behind the fraud.

Another senior banker noted that mid-sized and small lenders may see a short-term impact in terms of government entities parking their money with State-owned lenders, but this may not last long, as public sector banks, too, have faced material frauds in the past and are relatively less agile than private banks on technology infrastructure.

“The IDFC First Bank fraud, it appears, occurred due to connivance between bank employees, third-party broker and possibly Haryana State government department officials. Banks can build all the processes, but when employees act in connivance with third-party individuals, it becomes tough to spot frauds,” they said.

The banker observed that most frauds in the banking industry were on the advances side in the past, but, over the last five years, frauds have increased on the deposit side. These include mule accounts, digital frauds, micro-deposit schemes fraud, cheque fraud, and account takeover fraud, among others.

“A customer used to trust her banker as much as her doctor. But over the last 10-15 years bankers have lost that trust. Some engage in quick money-making schemes, and often lose money by trading in risky instruments like F&O. Under severe debt stress, they engage in fraudulent practices. Sometimes they may act in connivance with private individuals, as was seen in IDFC’s case, and sometimes they may move money from dormant accounts,” the banker said.


How the ₹590-crore fraud unfolded at IDFC First Bank

Our Bureau Mumbai

Over the past four days, IDFC First Bank has faced a series of setbacks. Its shares hit the lower circuit, the government of Haryana has de-empanelled the bank from handling State government business, and the lender has appointed KPMG to carry out a forensic audit. These developments follow the ₹590 crore fraud uncovered at one of the bank’s branches in Chandigarh. businessline explains how the bank faced a material fraud:

What was the modus operandi of the fraud?

According to public statements made by the bank’s management, this was a cheque-based fraud, perhaps the oldest kind in the banking industry.

While an investigation is awaited to unearth the details, forged physical cheques may have been used by an external party, who was allegedly acting on behalf of the government department, and manipulated entries may have been made by bank employees to siphon off or transfer funds out of the government department’s bank accounts.

The bank’s controls (like maker-checker approvals and SMS alerts) apparently failed to catch these until the discrepancies were noticed. The bank management suspects that the external party, supposedly representing the government department, acted in connivance with bank employees, who cleared the cheques without extensive vetting.

How was the fraud identified?

The scale of the fraud was identified when a certain department of the Haryana government sought closure of its deposit account at IDFC First Bank and transfer the remaining funds to another bank. IDFC First Bank then observed certain discrepancies in the amount claimed by the department against the actual balance in the account.

From February 18, 2026, certain other Haryana government entities engaged with the bank with regard to their respective accounts. During this process, differences were observed between the balances in the account and the balances mentioned by the Haryana government entities holding accounts with the bank.

Post review, the bank said the scope of the fraud did not extend to other customers of the Chandigarh branch. It has still not clarified the period during which the amount was transferred to other accounts.

What action has the bank taken?

The bank has placed four branch officials under suspension pending investigation. Additionally, Haryana Chief Minister Nayab Saini said the government will form a high-level committee to identify and punish the perpetrators of this fraud, be they bank officials, third-party brokers or any government department official.


Agentic AI is projected to significantly compress white-collar labor in India, particularly within the information technology (IT) and services sectors, by shifting the focus from human productivity to task replacement.

The following factors detail how this compression is expected to unfold:

Stagnant Headcount Growth

Industry experts and reports from Nasscom indicate a decisive shift toward non-linear growth, where revenue can increase without a corresponding rise in headcount.

  • Net additions for FY26 are projected at a growth rate of only 2.3%, translating to just one lakh (100,000) new jobs across the entire sector.
  • Nasscom anticipates that job additions will remain stagnant for the next fiscal year and beyond.

Shift to Task Replacement

The evolution from generative AI to agentic AI marks a transition from simple task automation to systems that can enable decision-making and execute "next-best actions".

  • Markets are increasingly viewing these advanced models as task-replacement engines rather than just productivity enhancers.
  • AI agents are being formally integrated into teams to act on behalf of users, accessing files and executing workflows that previously required human intervention.
  • If a task is digital and does not require physical labor, AI is now increasingly capable of handling "micro-jobs" that once took a human an hour to complete.

Vulnerability of the "Middle Layer"

Experts are divided on which segment of the workforce will be most affected, but many point to the middle layer of the talent pool as the most vulnerable.

  • While younger generations may adapt quickly, the middle tier must transition and upskill at an accelerated pace to remain relevant.
  • Displaced middle-layer workers may increase competition for lower-end roles, potentially freezing wage growth and widening income inequality.

Disruption of Traditional Business Models

The IT services industry’s traditional effort-based billing models (based on man-hours) are under direct threat.

  • AI tools like Claude Code can compress modernization cycles for legacy systems—which traditionally required large teams and multi-year timelines—down to just quarters or even weeks.
  • As AI handles up to 90% of code generation, software becomes significantly cheaper to produce, leading to "massive perturbations" for legacy players.
  • Analysts warn of deflationary risks to sector revenues, as clients may demand a share of these efficiency gains, leading to lower realizations per man-hour.

** Gradual vs. Sudden Transition**

Despite these pressures, some leaders, such as HCLTech CEO C. Vijayakumar, argue that the transition will be gradual rather than dramatic due to the "big lag" between technological capability and actual enterprise deployment. They suggest that meaningful gains may take years to materialize as firms must first modernize legacy technology stacks to support AI.

Banks grapple with changing savings behaviour

K Srinivasa Rao

Banks need to deal with structural liquidity mismatches created by money moving into alternative investments from bank deposits.

The deepening of financial markets, along with increased financial literacy and quick access to bank savings through digital channels, has fuelled a gradual shift of bank deposits into alternative investments, including mutual funds, equities, bonds, small savings, G-secs, gold, silver, real estate, and derivatives.

The customer profile of banks is shifting toward young, tech-savvy customers having a higher risk appetite for exploring non-bank investment options. The increased flow of bank deposits moving back and forth between alternative investments in financial markets and the banking system in a different form is creating risks. The business model may need to be recalibrated to align with the evolving transformation in asset and liability composition, tenor, and pricing.

THE DEPOSIT CHURN

A common argument is that deposits that move to other institutions should eventually return to the banking system after the round trip, as the receiving institutions will use banks to route them. If a bank customer moves funds from a savings account to alternative financial instruments, the system’s liquidity might eventually recover, but the ALM structure and interest rates will change drastically. The flight of deposits from banks to financial markets and their return to banks will be subject to certain “liquidity leaks” and a major “pricing trap”.

While most money remains in the banking “pipes”, a significant portion leaves the system temporarily or permanently. Even when that money returns to the bank via a Mutual Fund Institution’s bank account, it is placed in high-cost bulk deposits or CDs (Certificates of Deposit), where the bank might have to pay 7.5 per cent or more.

Thus, banks might be losing low-cost retail deposits and replacing them with “expensive” wholesale funding, which narrows their net interest margin (NIM). This is why many banks introduce differentiated deposit schemes with attractive interest rates to prevent deposit outflows and protect their NIM.

LEAK OF LIQUIDITY

Not all deposits that leave the bank may return to the banking system, as some may go as taxes that get parked with the RBI, effectively withdrawing that money from the commercial banking system until the government spends it. As of early 2026, government cash balances have hovered between ₹1.5 lakh crore and ₹4 lakh crore, creating a temporary liquidity shortfall.

Physical cash withdrawals have surged, with currency withdrawals amounting to ₹4.4 trillion in the 14 months leading to January 2026—three times higher than the previous year’s trend. Every rupee held in a physical wallet cannot be multiplied as a bank deposit. Additionally, the RBI often sells dollars to stabilise the rupee, which permanently removes liquidity from the banking system.

The “churn” of money moving between banks and alternative investments creates constant friction, often choking banks’ lendable resources and slowing the velocity of money. Deposits don't simply “revolve” into alternative investment instruments; they create structural liquidity mismatches, higher funding costs, and systemic risks—despite total household savings remaining stable in the long run.

The RBI’s support through liquidity adjustment facility (LAF) can be only temporary. Ultimately, banks will need to recalibrate their business models to manage their operations while protecting their NIM. Through non-core banking services, banks should galvanise institutional accounts of wealth management entities and serve them with a priority tag.

Similarly, non-funded products should be used to serve corporate accounts actively raising funds through bonds and the ECB route, with specially trained employees to improve retention of funds. SLBC forums and lead bank relationships should be explored for government accounts. Banks will have to gear up for higher liquidity and pricing competition as deposits flee to other investment channels and lose much of their sheen on their return journey back to banks.

The writer is Adjunct Professor, Institute of Insurance and Risk Management. Views expressed are personal.


‘Per capita income acceleration faster than GDP growth rate’

Our Bureau Mumbai

The acceleration in India’s per capita income growth has been faster than its GDP growth, driven significantly by a decline in population growth, according to RBI Deputy Governor Poonam Gupta.

Speaking at the 14th Foundation Day Lecture of the Centre for Development Studies in Thiruvananthapuram on February 20, Gupta explained that while India’s population growth was traditionally much higher than the global average, it has declined rapidly over the years. Since 2014, India’s population growth has been on par with the world average.

DEMOGRAPHIC SHIFT

Gupta attributed the slowing population growth to a rapid decline in fertility rates since the 1980s, which has outpaced the decline in death rates. She noted that these trends reflect the impact of increasing prosperity and education levels on demography and are expected to continue, further aiding the rapid increase in per capita incomes.

INCOME MILESTONES

India’s per capita income has seen a dramatic rise over the last few decades:

  • 1981: $274
  • 1991: $306
  • 2024: $2,700 (a nearly 10-fold increase from 1981 levels)

The pace of this growth has accelerated significantly. While it took 23 years to double the per capita income starting from 1981, it increased almost five-fold in the subsequent 22 years.

FUTURE PROJECTIONS

Citing the IMF’s October 2025 World Economic Outlook, Gupta stated that per capita income is projected to continue its upward trajectory:

  • 2025: $2,818
  • 2026: $3,051
  • 2030: $4,346

GLOBAL FOOTPRINT

Since the early 1990s, the Indian economy has consistently outpaced global growth. Consequently, India’s share of the global economy has tripled, rising from 1.1 per cent in 1991 to 3.5 per cent in 2024.

Furthermore, India’s per capita GDP as a percentage of world per capita GDP has increased from 7 per cent in 1991 to nearly 20 per cent in 2024 in current US dollar terms. Gupta emphasized that in purchasing power parity (PPP) terms, India’s per capita GDP relative to the world average is even larger.


Tiruppur targets $10 billion exports to Europe

Our Bureau Chennai

India’s knitwear hub Tiruppur is positioning itself for its next growth leap as free trade agreements (FTAs) with the UK and the European Union near fruition, industry leaders said at a summit in Chennai on Tuesday.

“We have set an ambitious target of $10 billion in apparel exports by 2030,” said N Thirukkumaran, Chairman, Esstee Exports India Ltd, Tiruppur, and Secretary of the Tiruppur Exporters Association.

Currently, India’s total apparel exports stand at about $16 billion, with Tiruppur alone contributing nearly $5.2 billion—roughly a third of the country’s shipments. With the Prime Minister setting a national target of $40 billion in apparel exports by 2030, Tiruppur is expected to play a pivotal role.

GAME CHANGER

Exporters believe Europe will be a “game changer”. While India has already signed trade agreements with the UAE and other GCC countries, duty-free access to the UK and the EU could significantly improve Tiruppur’s competitiveness against rival sourcing hubs. Industry representatives noted that FTAs with a few European countries often open doors across the wider European market, multiplying export opportunities.

SUSTAINABILITY EDGE

A key differentiator for Tiruppur is its cluster-level sustainability framework. Unlike other global apparel hubs where compliance is limited to individual firms, Tiruppur operates common effluent treatment plants and shared ESG infrastructure, making it one of the few clusters globally aligned with emerging environmental and social disclosure norms. As sustainability becomes a baseline requirement for doing business, this advantage is expected to gain prominence.

STRATEGIC SHIFT

The Tiruppur cluster is also reorienting its growth strategy towards man-made fibre garments, athleisure, and value-added products, reflecting global consumption trends. Industry leaders expressed confidence that new investments in fibres such as lyocell in Tamil Nadu would strengthen competitiveness. Sunil Jhunjhunwala, Co-Founder of Techno Sportwear Pvt Ltd, added that the free and fair availability of raw materials and the mobility of the labour workforce will be critical for the industry's success.


59% winter rain deficit hits east & central parts badly

Vinson Kurian Thiruvananthapuram

Winter precipitation between January 1 and February 23 is 59 per cent below normal for the country, with only the South Peninsula (-24 per cent) seeing marginal benefit among the four regions, according to the India Meteorological Department (IMD).

East and North-East India recorded the steepest deficit at -92 per cent, followed by Central India at -81 per cent. The shortfall is attributed to fewer western disturbances carrying adequate moisture along the international border across Gujarat, south-west Rajasthan and Punjab.

BELOW-NORMAL VIEW

North-West India fared relatively better at -48 per cent, though the systems failed to penetrate eastward. Moisture supply from the Bay of Bengal remained weak, unlike the north-east Arabian Sea, which partly aided North-West India.

In its short-term outlook for February 26-March 4, the IMD said one or two feeble western disturbances may bring light to moderate rain/snow at isolated to scattered places over the hills of North-West India on a few days, but these would be insufficient to alter the overall situation.

Light precipitation may extend eastward to isolated areas of Sikkim and Arunachal Pradesh, but rainfall is likely to remain below normal across most parts of the country. Isolated rain/snow is expected over Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand on Friday and Saturday.

BETTER PROSPECTS

Long-range guidance from the Climate Forecast System and the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts indicate improving conditions from mid-March.

Western disturbance activity is expected to strengthen between mid-March and early April, peaking around March 25-April 3. Likely beneficiaries include Gujarat, west Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and west Uttar Pradesh.

Rainfall may be heavier over the hills of North-West India, parts of East and North-East India, and in the South over coastal Karnataka, Kerala and the adjoining Western Ghats, including south-west and south Tamil Nadu.


Kerala to be renamed Keralam soon

Shishir Sinha New Delhi

The Union Cabinet has approved the renaming, pending further legislative action and Presidential nod.

The Union Cabinet on Tuesday held its first meeting at ‘Seva Teerth’, the new office of the Prime Minister. It approved a proposal to rename Kerala as Keralam, among other decisions related to the Railways, power and agriculture.

“After the approval of the Union Cabinet, the President of India will refer a Bill, namely the Kerala (Alteration of Name) Bill, 2026, to the State Legislative Assembly of Kerala for expressing its views under the proviso to Article 3 of the Constitution,” Information & Broadcasting Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw told the media after the meeting.

According to an official release, after the receipt of the views of the Kerala Assembly, the Government of India will obtain the recommendation of the president for the introduction of the Kerala (Alteration of Name) Bill, 2026, in Parliament. The State Assembly had on June 24, 2024, adopted a resolution to change the name of the State to ‘Keralam’.

“The name of our State is ‘Keralam’ in the Malayalam language. States were formed on the basis of language on the 1st day of November 1956. The Kerala Piravi Day is also on the 1st day of November,” the Kerala Assembly resolution read.

“Since the time of the national independence struggle, there has been a strong demand for the formation of United Kerala for the people speaking the Malayalam language. But in the First Schedule to the Constitution, the name of our State is recorded as ‘Kerala’. This Assembly unanimously appeals to the Central government to take urgent steps as per Article 3 of the Constitution for modifying the name to Keralam,” the resolution added.

Thereafter, the Kerala government requested the Central government to take the necessary steps to amend the First Schedule to the Constitution by altering the name of ‘Kerala’ to ‘Keralam’, according to Article 3 of the Constitution.

PIQUANT PROBLEM

Meanwhile, ahead of the official announcement, Lok Sabha member from Thiruvananthapuram and senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor wrote in a social media post: “All to the good, no doubt, but a small linguistic question for the Anglophones among us: What happens now to the terms “Keralite” and “Keralan” for the denizens of the new “Keralam”? “Keralamite” sounds like a microbe and “Keralamian” like a rare earth mineral…! @CMOKerala might want to launch a competition for new terms resulting from this electoral zeal".

Monday, February 23, 2026

The Software Upgrade in Chinese Civic Behaviour

 In the provided sources, "software" is defined as civic behaviour, or what is domestically referred to in China as "civilisational levels" (wénmíng shuǐpíng). The evolution of this software is framed as a significant upgrade that has occurred alongside the country's massive "hardware" (infrastructure and building) improvements over the last two decades.

The Evolution from "Village" Norms to Urban Etiquette

In the early 2000s, Chinese cities, including Beijing and Shanghai, were described as having "much of the village about them". Civic behaviour during this era was characterized by several "lacunae" in social etiquette:

  • Public Habits: Casual spitting, littering, and disorderly queuing were common.
  • Social Interactions: Scant awareness of others’ personal or aural space, manifested through loud phone conversations and "Beijing-style name-calling".
  • Physical Deportment: Locals often hitched vests over their bellies in warm weather, and children frequently wore kaidangku (open-crotch pants) for convenience.
  • Sanitation: Public toilets were often unclean, and users frequently squatted on top of Western-style toilet seats.

By 2026, the sources describe a marked transformation. Observations at places like the Fragrant Hills in Beijing show improved crowd management and relative order despite massive tourist numbers. Public spaces have become "spick and span" with no litter in sight, and toilet seats are generally free of footprints, indicating a shift from squatting to sitting.

Drivers of the "Software Upgrade"

The sources identify several key factors that have propelled this evolution:

  • Economic Growth: As per capita income in Beijing rose from approximately USD 2,600 in 2005 to USD 13,000 in 2025, the population moved from "survival norms" toward "bourgeois self-regulation". Higher incomes have fostered a middle class with reputational stakes who care about refinement and social scrutiny.
  • Settled Urbanisation: The process of moving from rural to urban areas has transitioned into a "settling into" of urban norms, moving past the phase where the "village lingers in the city".
  • Hardware Influencing Software: The physical environment itself shapes behaviour; for instance, targeted afforestation (adding 2.19 million mu of green space) and the provision of ample dustbins and clean waterways encourage more respectful use of public space.
  • Increased Surveillance: The "panopticon" of pervasive surveillance cameras—estimated at 370 per 1,000 people in large cities—creates a sense of being constantly observed. This results in self-policing and reduces "behavioural slippage" into old habits like spitting or littering.

"Upgrade with Chinese Characteristics"

Despite these changes, the sources clarify that the evolution is an "upgrade with Chinese characteristics," rather than a total transformation into a nation of "synchronised swimmers". Some traditional behaviours persist:

  • Taoist Spirit: The "way of the Tao" remains alive in the intuitive and sometimes rule-bending habits of bicyclists who ignore one-way roads or zebra crossings.
  • Informality: "Pajama couture" is still seen in older neighbourhoods, and "nappers" can still be found on display beds in IKEA.

Ultimately, the Chinese are described as "natural loophole-finders" who exist in a constant state of tension between individualistic, jugaad-oriented instincts and the order-seeking, paternalistic dictates of the state.


The sources identify the "software upgrade" in Chinese civic behaviour—domestically referred to as "civilisational levels" (wénmíng shuǐpíng)—as a complex transformation driven by a combination of economic, social, environmental, and technological factors.

The primary drivers of this change include:

1. Economic Growth and "Bourgeois Self-Regulation"

The dramatic increase in wealth over two decades has significantly altered the public psyche.

  • Income Increase: In Beijing, per capita income rose from approximately USD 2,600 in 2005 to USD 13,000 in 2025.
  • Shift in Values: This fivefold increase facilitated a shift from "survival norms"—where people focus on getting by in a "dog-eat-dog world"—to "bourgeois self-regulation".
  • Reputational Stakes: A new middle class has emerged with "reputational stakes," leading individuals to care more about refinement and the social scrutiny of others.

2. Settled Urbanisation

The sources describe a "temporally compressed process of urbanisation" that has moved beyond mere physical migration.

  • Completion of Transition: While early 2000s Beijing was an "agglomeration of urban villages" where the "village lingered in the city," the current era marks a "settling into of urban norms".
  • Abstract Civic Space: Interactions have evolved from being based on personal reciprocity to being governed by abstract concepts of civic space.

3. Hardware Shaping Software

The physical environment is presented as a direct determinant of behavior, where "upgraded hardware has also boosted the software".

  • Infrastructure Design: The presence of ample dustbins, clean waterways, and broad roads naturally encourages more respectful and considered behavior.
  • Targeted Afforestation: The massive addition of greenery—2.19 million mu of green space and 103 million trees between 2012 and the early 2020s—has changed the "look and feel" of the city, promoting less littering and better public conduct.

4. The "Panopticon" of Surveillance

Technological monitoring acts as a powerful deterrent against "behavioural slippage".

  • Pervasive Monitoring: Large Chinese cities now have approximately 370 cameras per 1,000 people, many of which were installed during the pandemic and never removed.
  • Self-Policing: Because every infraction is potentially recorded, citizens anticipate being observed, which creates a sense of "someone is always watching". This ensures that even if surveillance didn't create the behavior, it prevents people from reverting to "bad but easy habits" like spitting.

5. Paternalistic State Directives

The government has played an active role in engineering behavior through specific indices and public messaging.

  • Civilisation-Evaluation Index: Authorities historically used a ranking system for neighbourhoods, rewarding traits like shared housework and book collections while penalising "black marks" like spitting or raising livestock at home.
  • Rule-Announcing: Public spaces, such as the Fragrant Hills, use loudspeakers for "strident rule-announcing" to manage massive crowds and maintain order.

Despite these drivers, the sources note that this remains an "upgrade with Chinese characteristics". The "Taoist spirit" persists in a constant tension with "Confucian bodies," meaning that while people are more disciplined, they remain "natural loophole-finders" who occasionally indulge in "rule-bending" or "pajama couture".


Despite the significant "software upgrade" in civic behavior, the sources emphasize that China has not become a "nation-sized team of synchronised swimmers". Several persistent characteristics remain deeply ingrained in the social fabric, leading the author to describe the transformation as an "upgrade with Chinese characteristics".

Key persistent characteristics include:

  • Ongoing Public Habits: While reduced, behaviors such as spitting, "chaos-shuffling," and rule-bending still occur frequently enough to remain recognizable to those familiar with older iterations of Chinese cities.
  • "Pajama Couture": In older hutong neighborhoods, wearing pajamas as public attire remains a "haute fashion" staple.
  • IKEA Napping: A specific tradition from the mid-2000s that persists is the sight of local residents napping on display beds in flagship stores like IKEA.
  • The "Taoist Spirit" of Bicyclists: The behavior of Beijing cyclists is cited as proof that a rebellious, intuitive spirit remains "alive and kicking". These cyclists often operate with a logic that ignores "trifles" like zebra crossings, one-way roads, and even security cameras.
  • "Natural Loophole-Finders": The sources conclude that the Chinese are fundamentally "natural loophole-finders" rather than strict rule-followers. They are described as being in a constant state of tension between their "individualistic, jugaad-oriented instincts" and the paternalistic, order-seeking demands of the state.

Ultimately, while surveillance and wealth have disciplined public deportment, these persistent traits suggest a population that remains "Taoists trapped in Confucian bodies," balancing personal convenience and intuition against a cultural conditioning toward obedienc